The official Sam Reid/Daniel Currie Memorial Eker Thread

[merantau]

Dan Currie's impact should not be measured by bald facts such as games played or possessions won.
No, his significance is rightly reflected by the fact that hid delisting was first reported on this site by a Woof member resident in Berlin. Thanks Jazzadogs

[jazzadogs]

Dan Currie's impact should not be measured by bald facts such as games played or possessions won.
No, his significance is rightly reflected by the fact that hid delisting was first reported on this site by a Woof member resident in Berlin. Thanks Jazzadogs

Berlin has seen some dark days, but none like this.

[Twodogs]

Berlin has seen some dark days, but none like this.

Heh! I watched both Downfall and Nuremberg last night. (Long night) Berlin wasn't exactly presented at its pristine best.


But, yeah, not even close to the devastation of Dan Curries delisting.

[Greystache]

Today's news just reflects the impatience and refusal to do the hard yards that has infiltrated AFL football. Everyone is seeking quick wins.

To think a talented young ruckman like Daniel Currie has simply been cast aside, when with just a bit more coaching, some development, and a few more years in the system he could've been ready to blossom as a player. What a waste. Big guys take more time, don't they know this?!

[Axe Man]

Sam Reid delisted again by GWS but will be re-rookied. Could he could lay claim to greatest surviving eker?

[LostDoggy]

Sam Reid delisted again by GWS but will be re-rookied. Could he could lay claim to greatest surviving eker?

If classic eker traits include very modest talent, but a solid citizen who is respected for his character and hard work and is a good role model around the team, then Sam would be the man.

[Sedat]

Sam Reid delisted again by GWS but will be re-rookied. Could he could lay claim to greatest surviving eker?

As an aside, Sam and his girlfriend were staying at the same hotel in Hoi An (Vietnam) that I was at on holiday a couple of weeks ago. He might be a struggling eker on the footy ground but he is an AFL HoF legend off it

[Twodogs]

As an aside, Sam and his girlfriend were staying at the same hotel in Hoi An (Vietnam) that I was at on holiday a couple of weeks ago. He might be a struggling eker on the footy ground but he is an AFL HoF legend off it

A one man footy trip? With his girlfriend.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Sam Reid delisted again by GWS but will be re-rookied. Could he could lay claim to greatest surviving eker?

Outstanding work Axe Man - I just logged in wanting to raise a glass to Sam Reid to see it already done!

There's a few on this board that celebrate the Eker - and Sam Reid's persistence in the face of considerable adversity is worthy of celebration

[Axe Man]

Some quality ekers on this list:

THE SEVEN LUCKIEST PLAYERS IN THE AFL

List management is an art form but sometimes club's hands are tied. Each year there are players who remain on lists for varying reasons, despite the fact their prospects are grim. We take a look at seven such players.

Kyle Cheney (Adelaide)

You can make a case for the former Hawk and Demon given he’s a minimum chips insurance policy, given the Crows are in the premiership window, but it’s break in case of emergency only. The 28-year-old gives his all but doesn’t have the package to compete in a strong side.

He will see the year out in the SANFL unless the injury curse strikes. Cheney didn’t play a senior game in 2017 because of persistent hamstring injuries, seeing a number of players surge past him in the pecking order.

Jarryd Blair (Collingwood)

Apart from occasional forward 50 tackles, the Magpie small forward doesn’t impact the game anywhere near enough, but somehow managed to play 12 games in 2017 for 11 goals. Last year he kicked 21 goals from 15 appearances. Since 2012, the 174cm Magpie has kicked 88 goals from 119 games at an average 0.7 a game. Blair signed a one-year deal for 2017, so he isn't safe given lists are yet to be finalised.

He is the epitome of a fan base whipping boy but continues to survive Bear Grylls style.

Aaron Black (Geelong)

Part of the answer to the question why he is still a Cat lies in the fact North Melbourne pays Black to play at another club. Even more damning is the fact the Roos traded him in return for pick 92, so desperate they were to remove him from the list.

What was clear at North crystalised further for Geelong as 2017 unfolded - the 26-year-old simply isn’t good enough.

Despite injuries to forwards Dan Menzel, Nakia Cockatoo, Lincoln McCarthy and Cory Gregson, on top of Tom Hawkins’ suspension, the former Roo was selected four times but played only one senior game after being dropped following Round 8. He is forging a successful career as a list clogger.

Chris Masten (West Coast)

The Eagles must be seriously re-thinking decision to sign the former top five draft pick to a long-term deal in 2016. By the middle of this season, the midfielder was so far on the outer he spent 11 of the season’s final 14 weeks in the WAFL, including snubs for West Coast's two finals.

The fact that no club bit during trade period further heightened the problem for the Eagles, given another summer won’t make the 28-year-old any faster or taller.

Nathan Freeman (St Kilda)

Had Freeman been drafted pick 52 instead of pick 10 (by Collingwood in 2013), it’s unlikely he’s still in the system. The Saints stuck their neck out by recruiting the playmaker, despite the fact injury cruelled his two years at the Magpies.

You have to think there is a big element of the Saints justifying their decision, but at some point, you’ve got to cut your losses and run. It’s not the first time the Saints have handled damaged goods after they took injury riddled North Melbourne wingman Jesse Smith at the end of 2009.

The difference is the club jettisoned Smith after one season, but are surging towards a third with Freeman, who is yet to play a senior game. Has a year to run on a three-year deal that, and bar a remarkable turnaround, is shaping as top five in the club’s all-time trade howlers.

Dawson Simpson (GWS)

He couldn’t believe his luck when Shane Mumford’s career ended in a puff of smoke, opening the door for Simpson to sign on another one-year deal. Teammates love him but it’s hard to envisage Simpson leading the ruck division to a flag, given he has not been able to cement himself as the number one ruckman, despite 10 years of trying.

Ben Griffiths (Richmond)

He has a year to run on his current deal, and has benefitted from the fact every other key tall not named Jack Riewoldt has been an abject failure.

Given the Tigers won the flag with a small forward set-up, and the fact Griffiths has never been able to establish himself as a regular senior player in eight years at the club – he’s played 63 games and never more than 16 in any one season – it’s hard to imagine the equation changing in 2018. Throw in concussion issues and the immediate future isn’t bright.

[Twodogs]

Aaron Mullett must have reached the lofty heights of an eker. He's even changed teams as a DFA in order to establish his credentials.

[Axe Man]

Aaron Mullett must have reached the lofty heights of an eker. He's even changed teams as a DFA in order to establish his credentials.

If he can squeeze out a few more mediocre years of avoiding contested situations he will have truly earned his eker status.

[Twodogs]

If he can squeeze out a few more mediocre years of avoiding contested situations he will have truly earned his eker status.

With the team changing thing would a true eker go from a top club to a bottom club or vice versa. Or it just doesn't matter because a real eker would do anything to stay on a list.

[Rocco Jones]

McKernan and Cheney have both secured contracts.

[LostDoggy]

Some quality ekers on this list:

THE SEVEN LUCKIEST PLAYERS IN THE AFL

List management is an art form but sometimes club's hands are tied. Each year there are players who remain on lists for varying reasons, despite the fact their prospects are grim. We take a look at seven such players.

Kyle Cheney (Adelaide)

You can make a case for the former Hawk and Demon given he’s a minimum chips insurance policy, given the Crows are in the premiership window, but it’s break in case of emergency only. The 28-year-old gives his all but doesn’t have the package to compete in a strong side.

He will see the year out in the SANFL unless the injury curse strikes. Cheney didn’t play a senior game in 2017 because of persistent hamstring injuries, seeing a number of players surge past him in the pecking order.

Jarryd Blair (Collingwood)

Apart from occasional forward 50 tackles, the Magpie small forward doesn’t impact the game anywhere near enough, but somehow managed to play 12 games in 2017 for 11 goals. Last year he kicked 21 goals from 15 appearances. Since 2012, the 174cm Magpie has kicked 88 goals from 119 games at an average 0.7 a game. Blair signed a one-year deal for 2017, so he isn't safe given lists are yet to be finalised.

He is the epitome of a fan base whipping boy but continues to survive Bear Grylls style.

Aaron Black (Geelong)

Part of the answer to the question why he is still a Cat lies in the fact North Melbourne pays Black to play at another club. Even more damning is the fact the Roos traded him in return for pick 92, so desperate they were to remove him from the list.

What was clear at North crystalised further for Geelong as 2017 unfolded - the 26-year-old simply isn’t good enough.

Despite injuries to forwards Dan Menzel, Nakia Cockatoo, Lincoln McCarthy and Cory Gregson, on top of Tom Hawkins’ suspension, the former Roo was selected four times but played only one senior game after being dropped following Round 8. He is forging a successful career as a list clogger.

Chris Masten (West Coast)

The Eagles must be seriously re-thinking decision to sign the former top five draft pick to a long-term deal in 2016. By the middle of this season, the midfielder was so far on the outer he spent 11 of the season’s final 14 weeks in the WAFL, including snubs for West Coast's two finals.

The fact that no club bit during trade period further heightened the problem for the Eagles, given another summer won’t make the 28-year-old any faster or taller.

Nathan Freeman (St Kilda)

Had Freeman been drafted pick 52 instead of pick 10 (by Collingwood in 2013), it’s unlikely he’s still in the system. The Saints stuck their neck out by recruiting the playmaker, despite the fact injury cruelled his two years at the Magpies.

You have to think there is a big element of the Saints justifying their decision, but at some point, you’ve got to cut your losses and run. It’s not the first time the Saints have handled damaged goods after they took injury riddled North Melbourne wingman Jesse Smith at the end of 2009.

The difference is the club jettisoned Smith after one season, but are surging towards a third with Freeman, who is yet to play a senior game. Has a year to run on a three-year deal that, and bar a remarkable turnaround, is shaping as top five in the club’s all-time trade howlers.

Dawson Simpson (GWS)

He couldn’t believe his luck when Shane Mumford’s career ended in a puff of smoke, opening the door for Simpson to sign on another one-year deal. Teammates love him but it’s hard to envisage Simpson leading the ruck division to a flag, given he has not been able to cement himself as the number one ruckman, despite 10 years of trying.

Ben Griffiths (Richmond)

He has a year to run on his current deal, and has benefitted from the fact every other key tall not named Jack Riewoldt has been an abject failure.

Given the Tigers won the flag with a small forward set-up, and the fact Griffiths has never been able to establish himself as a regular senior player in eight years at the club – he’s played 63 games and never more than 16 in any one season – it’s hard to imagine the equation changing in 2018. Throw in concussion issues and the immediate future isn’t bright.

I love the write up on Aaron Black. Classic eker. Just shows enough of a glimpse of genuine talent once in a blue moon to hang in there. To think Geelong still retain him is bizarre really. There is something satisfying about an eker who is still a bit of a lair (as long as he plays for another club).