The top 10 players in the competition?

[GVGjr]

No Bulldog players are allowed to be selected but who do you think are the best players in the competition?

It doesn't have to be in order either if that makes it easier.

[Go_Dogs]

I'll have a crack, not an easy task though:

1. Gary Ablett
2. Nick Riewoldt
3. Lenny Hayes
4. James Bartel
5. Luke Hodge
6. Lance Franklin
7. Sam Mitchell
8. Adam Goodes
9. Joel Selwood
10. Chris Judd

[The Coon Dog]

I have mine in alphabetical order.

Gary Ablett
Jonathon Brown
Lance Franklin
Adam Goodes
Lenny Hayes
Chris Judd
Sam Mitchell
Matthew Pavlich
Nick Reiwoldt
Matthew Scarlett

[LostDoggy]

Found this quite hard without doggies players..good thread.

Gary Ablett Jr. - Chris Judd - Dean Cox - Adam Goodes - Nick Riewoltd - Lance Franklin - Johnathan Brown - Brendan Fevola - Matthew Pavlich - Simon Black

[mighty_west]

In no particular order:

Gary Ablett
Luke Hodge
Lance Franklin
Chris Judd
Adam Goodes
Nick Riewoldt
Lenny Hayes
Jonathon Brown
Matthew Pavlich
Simon Black

[GVGjr]

In no order

Nick Riewoldt
Dean Cox
Gary Ablett
Lance Franklin
Matthew Pavlich
Chris Judd
Brendon Goddard
Brendon Fevola
Matthew Scarlett
Luke Hodge

Interesting that no Collingwood players have rated a mention yet.

[mighty_west]

Interesting that no Collingwood players have rated a mention yet.

The only Pie i considered was Dane Swan, but i just couldn't fit him in the top 10, Didak & Davis are far too inconsistant.

Pendlebury is rated highly, maybe i just haven't taken too much notice of him, i actually rate Higgins [same draft] higher, probably biased, but Higgins is also a match winning type.

[Go_Dogs]

Interesting that no Collingwood players have rated a mention yet.

I considered Swan for the final spot in my list, he gets a load of the ball but just doesn't have enough hurt factor with his possessions.

Pendlebury would be in the mix for a Top 20.





I find it interesting the number of key position players compared to mids. I highly considered Pavlich, but couldn't find room for him or Brown.

Also interesting that Scarlett appears a few times already. I guess I just underrate him a little as he has been a pretty consistently high-quality performer for a number of years now.

[Dancin' Douggy]

I can only think of six.
Pavlich
Ablett
Brown
Riewoldt
Goodes
Judd

[Rocco Jones]

1- Nick Riewoldt
2- Gary Ablett
3- Matthew Scarlett
4- Chris Judd
5- Jonathan Brown
6- Matthew Pavlich
7- Lenny Hayes
8- Brendon Goddard
9- Lance Franklin
10- Dean Cox

[anfo27]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Nick Riewoldt
3. Lance Franklin
4. Jonathan Brown
5. Adam Goodes
6. Joel Selwood
7. Lenny Hayes
8. Chris Judd
9. Luke Hodge
10. Matthew Scarlett

[Max469]

Chris Judd
Simon Black
Brendon Fevola
Matthew Scarlett
Luke Hodge
Nick Riewoldt
Adam Goodes
Gary Ablett
Lance Franklin
Matthew Pavlich

[hujsh]

Personally wouldn't have Selwood before Bartel/Corey in Geelong's top 10. Surprised to have seen him twice so far.

[The Coon Dog]

Personally wouldn't have Selwood before Bartel/Corey in Geelong's top 10. Surprised to have seen him twice so far.

How about letting us in on your top 10 then hujsh.

[immortalmike]

I'll have a crack...

1.Ablett
2.Brown
3.Scarlett
4.Goodes
5.Reiwoldt
6.Judd
7.Pavlich
8.Franklin
9. Selwood
10. Hayes

That was tougher than I thought. I just rated on who I'm most scared of when they play against us.