Originally Posted by
mjp
OK.
On a total output basis, yes.
On a 'influence the game' basis, No. Aker was magnificent in the last quarter against Melbourne when it really counted, sliced Collingwood up in the 3rd quarter especially when the game was on the line, kicked two early against the Lions to shut them up and two late against the Dorkers to put any thought of a comeback out of their tiny minds.
I think Aker has been good at important times, though average in the main. I think Eagle has been OK, and has not reached any great heights at all.
He does not deserve the flack he is copping from some supporters though - he remains in our best 22, and it isn't even close.