Round 9 Discussion

[Remi Moses]

Cats and Blues staged a titanic struggle, those watching Channel 7's delayed disgrace look away now. Very good win in such an emotional week for Geelong.Personally not convinced by Carlton's forward half in big games, unfortunately the cheats look like top 4!

[Desipura]

Cats and Blues staged a titanic struggle, those watching Channel 7's delayed disgrace look away now. Very good win in such an emotional week for Geelong.Personally not convinced by Carlton's forward half in big games, unfortunately the cheats look like top 4!

If Carlton are top 4 and Collingwood, Geelong and Essendon, where does that leave us?

[aker39]

If Carlton are top 4 and Collingwood, Geelong and Essendon, where does that leave us?

5th

[Remi Moses]

If Carlton are top 4 and Collingwood, Geelong and Essendon, where does that leave us?

On current form we're not there obviously, having said that there is a large chunk of the season to go. Personally I think you can throw a blanket after Collingwood and Geelong over the rest. Carlton talking up the return of Kruezer have to remember he's 6 ft 5 coming of a knee reco!

[Greystache]

5th

Generously!

[chef]

If Carlton are top 4 and Collingwood, Geelong and Essendon, where does that leave us?

Lucky to make the eight.

[LostDoggy]

Is this another whinge thread or a round 9 discussion thread?

[Flamethrower]

An interesting post script to the game last night. Did anyone notice that Warnock was bleeding from the wound sustained from Enright's wayward spoiling attempt that led to the free kick - Jeff Garlett was the closest to Warnock, so if the ump was on the ball and sent him off under the blood rule, perhaps the Blues may have got the chocolates last night. Garlett is a far more relaible kick for goal than the ruckman.

[Sockeye Salmon]

An interesting post script to the game last night. Did anyone notice that Warnock was bleeding from the wound sustained from Enright's wayward spoiling attempt that led to the free kick - Jeff Garlett was the closest to Warnock, so if the ump was on the ball and sent him off under the blood rule, perhaps the Blues may have got the chocolates last night. Garlett is a far more relaible kick for goal than the ruckman.

Warnock should have told the ump then himself

[immortalmike]

Is this another whinge thread or a round 9 discussion thread?

It seems to be both.

[Ghost Dog]

Lucky to make the eight.

Walker is looking much better in the fwd line isn't he chef? Much improved.
I had no idea he was an indigeneous player!
Certainly not shy about going for a big grab.
There was one last night, if he had held on to, would have been an absolute screamer.

[chef]

Walker is looking much better in the fwd line isn't he chef? Much improved.
I had no idea he was an indigeneous player!
Certainly not shy about going for a big grab.
There was one last night, if he had held on to, would have been an absolute screamer.

His dad is full and his mum is Anglo. He comes from a very nice family.

He would be handy right now and would fit into our forward line perfectly.

[chef]

Is this another whinge thread or a round 9 discussion thread?

Who's whinging?

[Mantis]

He would be handy right now and would fit into our forward line perfectly.

If our 'best 22' our forwardline probably looks something like:

HF - Higgins, Grant, Sherman
F - Minson, Hall, Gia

Who's spot does Walker take?

[Desipura]

If our 'best 22' our forwardline probably looks something like:

HF - Higgins, Grant, Sherman
F - Minson, Hall, Gia

Who's spot does Walker take?

On current form Gia, Grant, Sherman or Higgins. I would add Hall however Walker is not a full forward