Daisy staying at pies

[LostDoggy]

Why ?

When in the past 10+ years have Collingwood lost any player they desired to keep on the list

Nick Davis

[Doc26]

Collingwood will keep everyone - they will loose a mid before they loose a quality big forward like Dawes who is as rare as hens teeth

When was the last time that Collingwood lost a player that they didnt want to keep?

Shaw to Sydney?

Can recall Rhyce being on the nose at Collingwood after the drink driving caper with his brother. Not sure the Collingwood hierarchy lost much sleep with his departure at the time. He became the collateral damage.

Nick Davis is the only one I can think off. Ask Collingwood supporters about him now, they're still livid about i.

Fair call on Davis although can't recall the lure of money being a factor. Wasn't he homesick ?

[Topdog]

Yeah Ryhce was shipped off so they could keep Heath and Didak.

[Desipura]

The pies lost Davis, though they preferred to keep him, he was a loose canon so they were not devestated.
The pies have not lost many over the last 20 years or so.

[Sockeye Salmon]

They lost Ron Todd to Williamstown in 1940

[Go_Dogs]

Interesting that he signed up for 2 years, which means the second GWS year is also ruled out. I would have thought a player like Thomas would've been better to sign a one year deal, and then try to get a bigger deal this time next year.

Perhaps it is lined up for when he'll reach the FA limit?

[KT31]

Gee I thought I was Cynical.

Obviously never met SS.