Round 23 discussion

[Sedat]

Collingwood were systematically brutal against a wounded opponent.

Geelong lost at their fortress against a fanatical opposition who implemented one-on-one all over the ground.

West Coke won ugly on the road as a good team does.

St Kilda once again expose North's feeble underbelly. Ziebell's apology to Riewoldt says everything about North's mindset - nstead of offering a hand, he should have barged into him and told him next time he won't be getting up. It was a show of intimidation by a young emerging player/team in reverence to a hardened team of old pros. We are similarly far too nice and genteel in the heat of battle.

[Remi Moses]

Collingwood were excellent against a wounded opponent.
Saw an untypical Sydney effort a few weeks back, saw a typical Sydney effort the last two.
Great Value for money.
True to form North talk the talk and then procede to get their pants pulled down.
No decent mid range players. Where was Wells ? Where was Harvey?Their supporter gobbed off all week about beating Stkilda.

[LostDoggy]

Anybody see Peter Faulk's injury? Horrible stuff, got a knee to the face, and i believe he has a broken jaw. Only his second AFL game as well

[G-Mo77]

Anybody see Peter Faulk's injury? Horrible stuff, got a knee to the face, and i believe he has a broken jaw. Only his second AFL game as well

Yeah that was horrible, applaud the brave effort though. There is nothing harder than running back like that into an oncoming forward. You know it's gunna hurt but you just have to go. I hope it's a speedy recovery.

From bravery to pathetic little pussies. Anyone see Brent Harvey slap a St. Kilda player in the face tonight? He then had the nerve to whine to an umpire about the rough treatment he was getting? Give me a break Boomer, find a hard ball once in a while! If you want to play soccer go right ahead.

[The Coon Dog]

Gee you have to admire Sydney, speaks volumes of the respect they have for their co-captain & I don't think anyone could begrudge them that win.

[GVGjr]

Gee you have to admire Sydney, speaks volumes of the respect they have for their co-captain & I don't think anyone could begrudge them that win.

To beat the Cats at their home ground given the week they all had was just a sensational result.

[Ghost Dog]

The Sunday Age describes Zeible's'martial arts ' move on Reiwoldt. SOUNDS COOL! any other details?

[Sedat]

From bravery to pathetic little pussies. Anyone see Brent Harvey slap a St. Kilda player in the face tonight? He then had the nerve to whine to an umpire about the rough treatment he was getting? Give me a break Boomer, find a hard ball once in a while! If you want to play soccer go right ahead.

The worst performance from a captain I've seen in a long time (excluding 'bruise-free' Brad Green of course). Boomer is deadly in a shootout but goes to water the minute there is any defensive pressure and accountability.

[Greystache]

From bravery to pathetic little pussies. Anyone see Brent Harvey slap a St. Kilda player in the face tonight? He then had the nerve to whine to an umpire about the rough treatment he was getting? Give me a break Boomer, find a hard ball once in a while! If you want to play soccer go right ahead.

It would be embarrassing to have him as your captain. Not just that incident, but several time he'd bump or wrestle a player, only to scream to the umpire for support the moment that player gives it back. There was one incident late in the game when Norf were getting smashed, Harvey grabbed a Saints player 100m off the play and tried to throw him into the ground, he couldn't do it so dived himself and screamed at the umpire for not giving him a free. Just pathetic.

[Remi Moses]

Blumey, Essendon and Carlton in two weeks!
Bit like Which arm would you like removed, think The Bombres will get pantsed .
Watched a bit of the Tiger Crows game which looked like an end of season pressure free feel about it.

[Greystache]

I went to the game tonight, wow Butcher is an impressive young player. His positioning is poor and he can't time his leads very well, but he is brilliant in the air. He has so much upside.

If there's any chance of him wanting to move back to Victoria I'd be all over him.

[LostDoggy]

Richmond a big chance to finish 9th.

[Ghost Dog]

That would be funny

[LostDoggy]

That would be funny

It's funny cos every year they build their hopes up winning meaningless games at the end of the season. Come first game of the next season, those hopes are smashed.