Welcome to the Bulldogs: Bailey Smith

[bornadog]

Makes you wonder what we could have got if we traded him last year.

I'm ****ing sick of losing good players. The more things change, the more they stay the same.

Which GOOD players have we lost under Bevo reign? Dunks and ????

[Grantysghost]

Which GOOD players have we lost under Bevo reign? Dunks and ????

Baz

[bornadog]

Baz

wasn't that the wrong answer some pages back? Last time I checked he was in OUR rehab group

[Hotdog60]

Which GOOD players have we lost under Bevo reign? Dunks and ????

Cordy

[AshMac]

Makes you wonder what we could have got if we traded him last year.

I'm ****ing sick of losing good players. The more things change, the more they stay the same.

Ditto. In essence we practically got 2 second round picks for Dunkley.

We paid 2 second round picks for Lobb.

[bornadog]

Cordy

You do have a sense of humour

PS: dropped this week, reason managed

[Mofra]

Cordy

118 games from a 4th round draft pick?

Sign me up every. single. time.

[jeemak]

118 games from a 4th round draft pick?

Sign me up every. single. time.

Who also took his moments in two of the clubs biggest games in its history.

[mjp]

Who also took his moments in two of the clubs biggest games in its history.

I'm all about the Zaine appreciation as well - he's had a great career - but are we seriously saying he is a player who we were desperate to retain who left?

Every selection thread in his last season was all "drop Zaine" + "Zaine is hopeless" type stuff...

The answer to the 'OTHER' (than Dunks) good players we've lost under Bevo is:

- Stringer.
- Hunter
- Lipinski (debatable)
- Adams (got injured so everyone forgets)
- Hamling (was covered up in family stuff so all forgiven)

[G-Mo77]

Ditto. In essence we practically got 2 second round picks for Dunkley.

We paid 2 second round picks for Lobb.

Absolutely awful deal. We continue to give these players away for virtually nothing which in turn hurts our depth, which was once a strength of ours. Macrae and Daniel are apparently no longer needed and will give them away for a bag of chips and pay their salaries. At what point do our list managers come under fire? It's disgraceful.

[Grantysghost]

I'm all about the Zaine appreciation as well - he's had a great career - but are we seriously saying he is a player who we were desperate to retain who left?

Every selection thread in his last season was all "drop Zaine" + "Zaine is hopeless" type stuff...

The answer to the 'OTHER' (than Dunks) good players we've lost under Bevo is:

- Stringer.
- Hunter
- Lipinski (debatable)
- Adams (got injured so everyone forgets)
- Hamling (was covered up in family stuff so all forgiven)

Hunter is the one many forget. We have battled to replace him.

[G-Mo77]

Hunter is the one many forget. We have battled to replace him.

Have we finished paying for him yet?

[Grantysghost]

Ditto. In essence we practically got 2 second round picks for Dunkley.

We paid 2 second round picks for Lobb.

For Dunks we got :

Pick 21 - 2022 (Charlie Clarke pushed to pick 24)

Future first (2023) - They were runner up so pick 17 which we used to get pick 5 in pick swap with Gold Coast, who on traded it in a pick swap to North who eventually used it at pick 23 (Ryley Hardemann).

Future second (2023) - Pick 40 which ended up at the Saints as part of the Coffield trade. Can't work out where it was used.

Future fourth (2023) - Pick 67 not used.

We gave :

Dunks
Future third (2023) - Used in Gunston trade in pick swaps so landed at Hawks
Future third (2023) - This is Hunter as we got it from Dees for him.
Also used in Gunston deal.

Basically

Out: Dunkley, Hunter, future third

In: Clarke, part of Sanders, Coffield

[The bulldog tragician]

I'm all about the Zaine appreciation as well - he's had a great career - but are we seriously saying he is a player who we were desperate to retain who left?

Every selection thread in his last season was all "drop Zaine" + "Zaine is hopeless" type stuff...

The answer to the 'OTHER' (than Dunks) good players we've lost under Bevo is:

- Stringer.
- Hunter
- Lipinski (debatable)
- Adams (got injured so everyone forgets)
- Hamling (was covered up in family stuff so all forgiven)

Jordan Roughead.

[bornadog]

I'm all about the Zaine appreciation as well - he's had a great career - but are we seriously saying he is a player who we were desperate to retain who left?

Every selection thread in his last season was all "drop Zaine" + "Zaine is hopeless" type stuff...

The answer to the 'OTHER' (than Dunks) good players we've lost under Bevo is:

- Stringer.
- Hunter
- Lipinski (debatable)
- Adams (got injured so everyone forgets)
- Hamling (was covered up in family stuff so all forgiven)

Stringer debatable - great talent poor output
Hunter - agree
Lippa debatable
Adams - nothing Special
Hamling - Couldn’t be helped
Roughead- I didn’t like losing him.

We are no different than every other club