The Moving/Rolling Trading & Delisting Thread 2018

[bulldogtragic]

Fingers crossed, that means a bid for west gets moved back one pick too meaning if we were to be in a points deficit, it would be a tiny bit less.

The AFEL like to make things more complex don't they? Add in making it a two day grab for attention, and possibly hand grenading priority picks around, then FS and NGAs, and their make up of FA compo despite the criteria they have. I guess it makes for a very interesting time for Power and his team.

[hujsh]

And I think both them and Carlton will land PP's.

We were at the bottom when GC and GWS got all those picks and now if they hand out two to GC and Carlton do we make a case for our own as compensation for being shafted by the AFL?

[ledge]

I wonder when the AFL realises that it’s the culture and the development at the clubs that lets players down and giving them a top pick more likely destroys a kids career than improves it or the team.
Eg Carlton have had so many first round draft picks and are as bad as ever, do you keep sending kids to a club hoping the kid fixes it or do you say no more destroying kids careers, get your club and development in order first.

[Twodogs]

We were at the bottom when GC and GWS got all those picks and now if they hand out two to GC and Carlton do we make a case for our own as compensation for being shafted by the AFL?

Don't be silly. Getting stuffed around by the AFL is our Raison D'être.

I wonder when the AFL realises that it’s the culture and the development at the clubs that lets players down and giving them a top pick more likely destroys a kids career than improves it or the team.
Eg Carlton have had so many first round draft picks and are as bad as ever, do you keep sending kids to a club hoping the kid fixes it or do you say no more destroying kids careers, get your club and development in order first.

Pretty soon a kid will refuse to go to Carlton and he'd be well within his rights. Footy is all about challenging yourself and improving your game. Carlton are so far from being that environment at the moment.

[ratsmac]

I wonder when the AFL realises that it’s the culture and the development at the clubs that lets players down and giving them a top pick more likely destroys a kids career than improves it or the team.
Eg Carlton have had so many first round draft picks and are as bad as ever, do you keep sending kids to a club hoping the kid fixes it or do you say no more destroying kids careers, get your club and development in order first.

Are there any players at Carlton worth looking at that may have been abused by Carlton's inept development that we might be able to rescue?

[Bulldog Joe]

Are there any players at Carlton worth looking at that may have been abused by Carlton's inept development that we might be able to rescue?

We already did that.. Billy Gowers.

Didn't work as well with Mark Austin

[EasternWest]

Are there any players at Carlton worth looking at that may have been abused by Carlton's inept development that we might be able to rescue?

There's an athletic beast ripe for the picking.

[Twodogs]

We already did that.. Billy Gowers.

Didn't work as well with Mark Austin

Apart from Phil Maylin and Billy Gowers have we ever recruited a decent player from Carlton?
‎

[Twodogs]

There's an athletic beast ripe for the picking.

And he must have a contract year coming up soon so you will get some good footy.

[EasternWest]

And he must have a contract year coming up soon so you will get some good footy.

Punxsatawney Phil says 6 weeks of good footy.

[Twodogs]

Punxsatawney Phil says 6 weeks of good footy.

Oh well,it's 6 more weeks of good footy than he plays most years,

[Bulldog Joe]

Apart from Phil Maylin and Billy Gowers have we ever recruited a decent player from Carlton?
‎

Didn't Adrian Gallagher play ok for us in the 70s

[bornadog]

Apart from Phil Maylin and Billy Gowers have we ever recruited a decent player from Carlton?
‎

What about Klomp

[Mofra]

Apart from Phil Maylin and Billy Gowers have we ever recruited a decent player from Carlton?
‎

Did Simon Minton-Connell play at Carlton before we got him? He racked up a few clubs IIRC

[Sedat]

Did Simon Minton-Connell play at Carlton before we got him? He racked up a few clubs IIRC

Cooky as well. Great season in 1998 for us.