ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

[LostDoggy]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

A very good point. If nothing else, they should go back to all of the games where he accrued votes and shift everyone up a place ie If he polled three votes then the player who polled two gets awarded three and the player that was awarded one gets bumped up to two.

Edit: Just went back and looked through the 2012 count, shifting players up votes would not change the finishing positions of those below him.

If they pursued this course, they would have to shift players votes up for all votes won by any of the banned EFC players. In some games, this'd be all 6 votes. Not really practical. I agree with those who say that the Brownlow for the year just becomes an asterisk.

[1eyedog]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

If they pursued this course, they would have to shift players votes up for all votes won by any of the banned EFC players. In some games, this'd be all 6 votes. Not really practical. I agree with those who say that the Brownlow for the year just becomes an asterisk.

Stained for eternity

[jeemak]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

This is a circus to the very end.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/essendon-swiss-court-decision-asada-chief-ben-mcdevitt-hits-out-at-the-bombers-20161012-gs0hco.html

[bulldogtragic]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

This is a circus to the very end.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-new...12-gs0hco.html

If he keeps it, I want Gordo to bang on about Chris Grant being given one. At the Grand Final presser, Gordo actually brought up the issue of Chris Grant's Brownlow, or should've been. So Gordo is onto it.

[Daughter of the West]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

This is a circus to the very end.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-new...12-gs0hco.html

FFS. The guy is now a convicted drug cheat, and he gets to argue why he should keep a best and FAIREST medal?

Why is that even a thing?!?!?

[Bornadog]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

FFS. The guy is now a convicted drug cheat, and he gets to argue why he should keep a best and FAIREST medal?

Why is that even a thing?!?!?

Don't worry, he lost his phone and the AFL will let him keep the Brownlow.

[hujsh]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

If Essendon use their 1st pick to bid for the GWS and GC academy players then he can keep it as a reward.

[Twodogs]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

If Essendon use their 1st pick to bid for the GWS and GC academy players then he can keep it as a reward.

I know how I would like to see their first pick used. Straight up their jacksie

[Twodogs]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

"The SFT determined that since the players did not formally challenge the jurisdiction of CAS during the arbitration procedure and accepted the application of the CAS Rules (including the rule providing for a de novo hearing (i.e. for a procedure allowing the CAS to conduct a full review of the case), they had lost their right to challenge the CAS jurisdiction in appeal.

I always said the only way to win this was to go WADA and CAS *!*!*!*!ing hard and destroy one or the other (like the Russians are doing-WADA will regret picking that fight) but the AFEL wimped it majorly.

[SlimPickens]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

Possibly a question for a thread of its own, but if Watson has his medal taken off him does it automatically go to runners up Mitchell and Cotchin?

I’m not convinced it does. It’s not as simple as Watson finished a race first, and if he wasn’t a drug cheat, Mitchell and Cotchin would’ve finished ahead of him. Watson was playing games while doping which means players who were competing fairly missed opportunities to gain the votes that he shouldn’t have received. Who’s to say if Watson hadn’t doped, Ablett or Swan wouldn’t have be awarded the votes he got and went on to win, with Mitchell and Cotchin still finishing 2nd? Hawthorn only played Essendon once, where Collingwood played them twice. Watson interfered with the final result and in doing so corrupted the entire event.

I’m of the view he gets stripped of the award and no winner is declared.

It's a moot point however as suspended players can still receive votes. I guess the other thing that would also need to be factored in to your point is that other suspended Essendon players would have received votes throughout the year which may have affected the outcome.

So with that considered, no one gets the award IMO.

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

It's a moot point however as suspended players can still receive votes. I guess the other thing that would also need to be factored in to your point is that other suspended Essendon players would have received votes throughout the year which may have affected the outcome.

So with that considered, no one gets the award IMO.

Suspended players can get votes................but they can't win the Brownlow.
Having Jobe Watson going before a panel to argue his case is truly bizarre
It should be automatic and immediate.

[Twodogs]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

Suspended players can get votes................but they can't win the Brownlow.
Having Jobe Watson going before a panel to argue his case is truly bizarre
It should be automatic and immediate.

It's the stupidest decision anyone could come up with,

[Bornadog]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

Suspended players can get votes................but they can't win the Brownlow.
Having Jobe Watson going before a panel to argue his case is truly bizarre
It should be automatic and immediate.

Equally as bizarre they asked Cotchin and Mitchell to go before the panel and argue FOR receiving the Brownlow. Needless to say they said no.

The AFL is a truly *!*!*!*!ed up organisation.

[SlimPickens]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

Equally as bizarre they asked Cotchin and Mitchell to go before the panel and argue FOR receiving the Brownlow. Needless to say they said no.

The AFL is a truly *!*!*!*!ed up organisation.

The AFL want the easy out. "No, No Gil we couldn't possibly accept this medal. Why not let Jobe keep it!"

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: ASADA issues show-cause notices to Essendon players

equally as bizarre they asked cotchin and mitchell to go before the panel and argue for receiving the brownlow. Needless to say they said no.

The afl is a truly *!*!*!*!ed up organisation.

omg, is that true????????????