Other clubs trade activity

[Sedat]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

It wasn't super clear in my initial post, but Campbell being involved in a trade for Impey was what I was alluding to. Well aware that Trengove is a free agent.

The Ryder issue doesn't seem to be getting the coverage that it might deserve. There was a tweet from someone at the pub saying (paraphrase) "I just saw Paddy Ryder punch a cop. He can say goodbye to his career". If the allegations are accurate, what penalty does that carry?

They have Lobbe as the emergency break glass option, who is a better player than Campbell.

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Trade Radio (Yes they are back) have mentioned that Sydney have a strong interest in Jack Watts and a 2nd round pick might get it done.
If so I think that means Kurt Tippett would be on the market

Would we be interested in either of them?

[Remi Moses]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Other clubs trade activity
Everyone's going to Carlton

[ledge]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Other clubs trade activity
Everyone's going to Carlton

And Gibbs isn't going anywhere I think they will have about 60 players on the main list by the start of 2018 and no mention of the salary cap, unlike us we lose a captain and a Brownlow medallist and sign one player and Our salary cap is not enough.

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

They have Lobbe as the emergency break glass option, who is a better player than Campbell.

No he isn't. I've watched Lobbe closely three times in the SANFL this year and he was very ordinary (and soft as butter)


And with Ryder possibly unavailable now...

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Watts likely headed to Sydney
Lever nominates Melbourne
Kane Cornes says if a Melbourne club put a big offer to Rory Sloane, he might take it up
GCS demand a best 22 player for GAJ
Carlton deny interest in Gryphone

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

If we should get pick #11 for Stringer, and if the Crows should want two 2017 first rounders for Lever, would you trade our then pick #11 for the Dees 2018 first rounder?

[Happy Days]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

If we should get pick #11 for Stringer, and if the Crows should want two 2017 first rounders for Lever, would you trade our then pick #11 for the Dees 2018 first rounder?

Why would we do that? It's pretty likely they improve on this year's result, where they ended up with pick 10. Seems like a low-reward, high-risk route to take.

[Remi Moses]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

And Gibbs isn't going anywhere I think they will have about 60 players on the main list by the start of 2018 and no mention of the salary cap, unlike us we lose a captain and a Brownlow medallist and sign one player and Our salary cap is not enough.

I'll get it right
Every GWS reserves player is going to Carlton

[Axe Man]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Lever has formally asked the Crows for a trade to a Melbourne based club, no club nominated as yet.

[GVGjr]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

If we should get pick #11 for Stringer, and if the Crows should want two 2017 first rounders for Lever, would you trade our then pick #11 for the Dees 2018 first rounder?

If you assume the Dees will have a better season next year they would be better offering their 1st pick this year and next.
In your scenario we could be giving up pick 11 this year for pick 14 next year. It's a marginal call with a slight upside given next years draft should have a bit more top end talent. Essendon parting with pick 11 and us not giving something back is very unlikely.

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Why would we do that? It's pretty likely they improve on this year's result, where they ended up with pick 10. Seems like a low-reward, high-risk route to take.

Lets say the Dees finish 6th next year, then we would be trading pick #11 in a poor draft for pick#13 in a hot draft.

[GVGjr]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

Lets say the Dees finish 6th next year, then we would be trading pick #11 in a poor draft for pick#13 in a hot draft.

I don't agree with your poor draft rating. One is regarded as a super draft.

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

If you assume the Dees will have a better season next year they would be better offering their 1st pick this year and next.
In your scenario we could be giving up pick 11 this year for pick 14 next year. It's a marginal call with a slight upside given next years draft should have a bit more top end talent. Essendon parting with pick 11 and us not giving something back is very unlikely.

I suppose it is based on a lot better draft next year, and IF the Crows should want two 2017 first round picks.

Just a thought.

[Dry Rot]

Re: Other clubs trade activity

I don't agree with your poor draft rating. One is regarded as a super draft.

OK then an OK draft vs a super draft.