Impey trade worth

[Topdog]

So talk of the town is that we are after him.
It's probably BS just based on him having dinner with Bont but anyway...

What's he worth? What would you be willing to give up?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Impey trade worth

Key numbers

Draft pick 21, 2013 afl draft. 22 years, 75 games.

This year 20 games - 15 goals, 14 behinds - Average 12 disposals, 3 tackles, 3 inside 50's

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Impey trade worth

So talk of the town is that we are after him.
It's probably BS just based on him having dinner with Bont but anyway...

What's he worth? What would you be willing to give up?

I would say a pick in early-mid 20s.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Impey trade worth

I would say a pick in early-mid 20s.

Tend to agree. Scuttlebutt on here that Port want Watts and vice versa. He'd be worth the same.

Watts - Port
Impey - Dogs
Pick 26 - Melbourne (possibly lower with FA compo involved)

That then helps the Lever deal for Melbourne.

Not sure what role we have for him. His career and 2017 stats aren't great.

[azabob]

Re: Impey trade worth

I would say a pick in early-mid 20s.

I think he is closer to a pick in the 40’s. His disposal efficiency is only mid 60%.
Not sure other than pace what he will add to our side?

[ledge]

Re: Impey trade worth

It might be a player .. Honeychurch ?

[azabob]

Re: Impey trade worth

Tend to agree. Scuttlebutt on here that Port want Watts and vice versa. He'd be worth the same.

Watts - Port
Impey - Dogs
Pick 26 - Melbourne (possibly lower with FA compo involved)

That then helps the Lever deal for Melbourne.

Not sure what role we have for him. His career and 2017 stats aren't great.

As you alude to his stats are poor - why would you give up a second round pick for him?

[hujsh]

Re: Impey trade worth

Is he a potential Rioli type? Seems to have played more half back but given his height and disposal numbers JJ maybe be better suited there (especially with our defensive structure). Don't know if he's worth a mid 30s pick based on stats (hard to gauge potential not having seen him play much) but 30s might be right.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Impey trade worth

It might be a player .. Honeychurch ?

Maybe Crameri. Impey has 75 games and heading into his best years. Honeychurch has no runs on the board. But Crameri in a three way trade is closer to value I think.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Impey trade worth

As you alude to his stats are poor - why would you give up a second round pick for him?

I'm actually thinking that the more I ponder. Thinking especially of what we can get from Crameri. I think if we could get a 30's pick for Crameri, I'd be a lot more comfortable with that. Geelong have reportably made an offer to Stew for 2 years. If we could nab their pick 34, that's about right. Then 39 for Crozier. Trengove as a FA. Leaving 9 & 26 still in tact.

[azabob]

Re: Impey trade worth

If we trade Impey for pick 26 and Stringer for pick 11 we will see a melt down to end all melt downs.

[azabob]

Re: Impey trade worth

I'm actually thinking that the more I ponder. Thinking especially of what we can get from Crameri. I think if we could get a 30's pick for Crameri, I'd be a lot more comfortable with that. Geelong have reportably made an offer to Stew for 2 years. If we could nab their pick 34, that's about right. Then 39 for Crozier. Trengove as a FA. Leaving 9 & 26 still in tact.

BT I think you are being generous with Crameri value. We’d more likely get their third round at best.

[GVGjr]

Re: Impey trade worth

While he would provide us with an effective small forward and midfielder we don't necessarily need him.
If it means talking an extra pick to the draft then that might be best for us.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Impey trade worth

BT I think you are being generous with Crameri value. We’d more likely get their third round at best.

There would have to be some massaging. But 34 with possibly 4 free agent compos (Rockliff, Trengove, Motlop, other) makes it pick 38. Crameri for about pick 40 isn't too bad a deal. By the time they've finished with GAJ they'll likely have a new set of numbers.

Would Port take 38 for him? He's under contract, so I don't think so. But I'm not sure what role he's going to play. If it's because he's quick, I'd rather spend more on Saad. I get the link with Trengove, but on our list, im just trying to see how much he's going to add on the ground.

[Bullies]

Re: Impey trade worth

Supporters of Port don't rate him highly at all.