1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

[bulldogtragic]

Strongly Rumoured In (RI), Strongly rumoured Out (RO)

Very rough Breakdown heading into the trade period: (in no particular order yet)

Players In - Players Out

Dogs: Bruce & Keath - Nil
Carl: Betts, Pittonet - Phillips
Hawks: Frost, Patton - Birchall, Pittonet
St Kilda: Hill, Ryder, Howard, Butler, Jones - Bruce, Acres, Steven


WCE: Tim Kelly - Nil
Melb: Tomlinson, Langdon - Frost
Coll: Cameron - Aish
GCS: Greenwood, Ellis - Ah Chee
GWS: Jacobs - Patton, Tomlinson, Bonar
Bris: Ah Chee, Ellis-Yolman - Nil
Syd: Nil - Jones
Gell: Steven, Jenkins - Tim Kelly
Freo: Acres, Aish - Hill, Langdon


North: Bonar - RO: Nil
Rich: Nil - RO: Ellis
Port: Nil - Ryder, Frampton, Howard
Adel: Frampton - Keath, Betts, Greenwood, Ellis-Yolman, Jacobs, Jenkins



As trades happen, I will move them around and we can assess the best performed club overall for players, picks and improvements of the list and value/cost of trades. You know, the many & varied factors that get assessed by reasonable people in making a conclusion.


This is a non-Dodoro thread.

[The Doctor]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

And he winner is awarded the presitigous 'Dodoro Medal'.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

And he winner is awarded the presitigous 'Dodoro Medal'.

I love it. I wish I had thought of that.

[ratsmac]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Adel RO the Couches to GCS

[jeemak]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

And he winner is awarded the presitigous 'Dodoro Medal'.

I love it. I wish I had thought of that.

I love how BT calls this a non-Dodoro thread and the first reply is Dodoro related and BT LOVES IT!

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

I love how BT calls this a non-Dodoro thread and the first reply is Dodoro related and BT LOVES IT!

As in Dodoro can't create a username and vote for himself. Which could happen with trade week winner being on the line.

[Bornadog]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

And he winner is awarded the presitigous 'Dodoro Medal'.

Hard to beat the previous two years winners

[hujsh]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Thead is so non-Dodo that Essendon aren't even in the tier list.

Is it just fairer to leave them out so we can have an actual competition?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Update:

Strongly Rumoured In (RI), Strongly rumoured Out (RO)

Very rough Breakdown heading into the trade period: in no particular order in the brackets

Higher Tier

Dogs: RI: Bruce & Keath - RO: Nil
Carl: RI: Papley, Martin, Betts - RO: Nil
Hawks: RI: Frost, Patton - RO: Birchall
St Kilda: RI: Hill, Ryder, Jones, Butler, Howard - RO: Bruce, Stevem, Acres, Newnes, McKenzie
WCE: RI: Tim Kelly - RO: Nil (lots of picks)


Mid Tier

Melb: RI: Tomlinson, Langdon - RO: Frost
Coll: RI: Cameron - RO:
GCS: RI: Greenwood, Ellis, B. Crouch - RO: Martin, Ah Chee
GWS: RI: Jacobs - RO: Patton, Tomlinson
Bris: RI: Ah Chee, Ellis-Yolman - RO: Robertson
Syd: RI: Daniher, McKenzie - RO: Jones
Gell: RI: Jenkins, Steven (lots of picks) - RO: Tim Kelly
Freo: RI: Nil (Picks) - RO: Hill, Langdon


Lower Tier

Ess: RI: Nil - RO: Daniher, Fantasia
North: RI: Nil - RO: Nil
Rich: RI: Nil - RO: Ellis, Butler
Port: RI: Robertson, Fantasia - RO: Ryder, Frampton, Gray, Powell Pepper & Howard
Adel: RI: Frampton - RO: Keath, Betts, Greenwood, Ellis-Yolman, Jacobs, Jenkins, B. Crouch

[Twodogs]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

I put in a poll but there are a couple of spots left Anymore for anymore BT?

[Twodogs]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

I love how BT calls this a non-Dodoro thread and the first reply is Dodoro related and BT LOVES IT!

I think it might be the best thing I have read this year!


It's the greatest non-Dodoro thread ever written.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

I put in a poll but there are a couple of spots left Anymore for anymore BT?

Maybe Melbourne.

I hoped this thread might have a big more activity. With under 72 hours, here's hoping something happens, anything. I start taking trade nominations for a playlist of 80's hair bands.

Anyone trade Cheap Trick for White Snake, Bad English & a future pick of David Lee Roth, as a stand alone act, post mid 80's Van Halen?

[Twodogs]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Maybe Melbourne.

I hoped this thread might have a big more activity. With under 72 hours, here's hoping something happens, anything. I start taking trade nominations for a playlist of 80's hair bands.

Anyone trade Cheap Trick for White Snake, Bad English & a future pick of David Lee Roth, as a stand alone act, post mid 80's Van Halen?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWIo2S2RGhI

[bulldogtragic]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Strongly Rumoured In (RI), Strongly rumoured Out (RO)

Very rough Breakdown heading into the trade period: (in no particular order yet)

Players In - Players Out

Dogs: Bruce & Keath - Nil
Carl: Betts, Pittonet - Phillips
Hawks: Frost, Patton - Birchall, Pittonet
St Kilda: Hill, Ryder, Howard, Butler, Jones - Bruce, Acres, Steven


WCE: Tim Kelly - Nil
Melb: Tomlinson, Langdon - Frost
Coll: Cameron - Aish
GCS: Greenwood, Ellis - Ah Chee
GWS: Jacobs - Patton, Tomlinson, Bonar
Bris: Ah Chee, Ellis-Yolman - Nil
Syd: Nil - Jones
Gell: Steven - Tim Kelly
Freo: Acres, Aish - Hill, Langdon


North: Bonar - RO: Nil
Rich: Nil - RO: Ellis
Port: Nil - Ryder, Frampton, Howard
Adel: Frampton - Keath, Betts, Greenwood, Ellis-Yolman, Jacobs, Jenkins



As trades happen, I will move them around and we can assess the best performed club overall for players, picks and improvements of the list and value/cost of trades. You know, the many & varied factors that get assessed by reasonable people in making a conclusion.


This is a non-Dodoro thread.

Winners??


Carlton fans will be crying into pillows tonight. Offered Martin & 15 for 9, and said no... Should've picked us Jack.

St Kilda brought 5 in, lost three on their best 22 though. And paid about $2.5M to the new faces.

[The Doctor]

Re: 1st Annual Actual Winner of the Trade Period - 2019

Dodo

1. Made the Kelly deal happen even when it had nothing to do with him
2. Got Fantasia when he looked gone for all money and gave up nothing for him
3. Daniher ditto
4. The big one. Got Phillips
5. Another big one. Got Cutler another outside midfielder to add to their stockpile. Heaven help the rest of us if they get the ball outside of the inside.