Delisting and Retirements - 2021

[GVGjr]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

100% with you GG. I quite like big Levi, he sure can clunk a good mark & is not pushed around easily. Agree though - goal kicking with him & Naughty would make as all tear our hair out (even more then now). Can Levi ruck OK? Is he reasonably mobile? Perhaps part time only in forward line?

Casboult is a fine example of a limited player who showed improvement in his goal kicking later in his career.
All these nonsense excuses that get offered up about players missing goals because they're fatigued during games rather than acknowledging they have a flaw in their technique and working on that really does limit players from improving.

Casboult is OK in the ruck for 5 to 10 minutes a quarter.

[Jeanette54]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

The players definitely wouldn't want him.

Like most, I have no idea what he actually said, but.....

So we practice cancel culture, and send him packing forever for one thoughtless act. Let he who has not sinned cast the first stone.

[Mofra]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Casboult is a fine example of a limited player who showed improvement in his goal kicking later in his career.
All these nonsense excuses that get offered up about players missing goals because they're fatigued during games rather than acknowledging they have a flaw in their technique and working on that really does limit players from improving.

Casboult is OK in the ruck for 5 to 10 minutes a quarter.

It's not the worst suggestion. He came fifth in Carlton's B&F one year playing half the season in defence.
We're lauding Schache for producing in one game Casboult produced in 10

[Grantysghost]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Like most, I have no idea what he actually said, but.....

So we practice cancel culture, and send him packing forever for one thoughtless act. Let he who has not sinned cast the first stone.

No I actually don't think he should be run out of the game to he honest and hope his career doesnt end on this sour note.

He has had a great year been very impressive and that sort of player alone is certainly attractive.

However from our teams point of view I believe there would be certain players who would struggle with Tex coming into the fold after this incident.

Aside from that I'm not sure how long he has left and I'd rather get games into Jamarra and use Tim forward.

[josie]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Like most, I have no idea what he actually said, but.....

So we practice cancel culture, and send him packing forever for one thoughtless act. Let he who has not sinned cast the first stone.

It’s an interesting dilemma for sure. Part of me says if the fabric of a club is strong and if Tex truly can make reparations beyond his apology in a way that truly makes a positive contribution then why not. The overall outcome (not considering footy performance) might be more positive for society, the club that considers him and Tex himself than simply writing him off. The other part of me thinks with the stretched resources at clubs and the danger of players seeing his acquisition as a negative then it’s not worth the risk. I also do not know if Tex has a history of racial blindness or other stupid acts so that’s a big consideration too. There’d have to be a lot of internal consultation before such a decision could be made.

Whatever happens I do hope Tex can somehow contribute in a meaningful way to stamping out racism, whether that’s through deeds outside an AFL playing career or not.

To me zero tolerance needs to co-exist within a society where one, albeit disgraceful, mistake does not mean a person is beyond redemption and nor should we treat them as if they are beyond it.

This a kind of long winded way of me agreeing with you Jeanette54!! Perhaps I should have just hit thanks button for making me think this through!!

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

What about Tex ??? He could fulfill the Bruce role, and is somewhat "tainted" at the moment, and could come cheap.

Would it be politically correct to offer him a lifeline if the Crows don't take him on again.

That's a HARD No from me.

[SquirrelGrip]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

He is actually better than you think.

Over his career he has kicked 154/112 or 58% accuracy - still not brilliant, but he has improved in his latter years

That doesn't include another 180 out on the full.

[GVGjr]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

What about Tex ??? He could fulfill the Bruce role, and is somewhat "tainted" at the moment, and could come cheap.

Would it be politically correct to offer him a lifeline if the Crows don't take him on again.

I remain convinced players can adapt and learn. Tex has made a huge error and deserves his whack but I don't think he should be written off as a player.

I doubt we would consider him but I think it's an error to write him off as a person or player. It can be a learning experience not just a hanging one.

[Axe Man]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

I hope Tex can play at the Crows next year and go some way to redeeming himself. I just can't see another club wanting to deal with the circus that would ensue if he continued his career elsewhere, especially for a player almost at the end. And that's before you even consider the wishes of the playing group, as previously mentioned.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

That doesn't include another 180 out on the full.

And 57 into the man on the mark xD

He has improved for sure, was it Sav Rocca that helped him out?

[Bornadog]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Cale Hooker retiring.

[macca]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Cale Hooker retiring.

One less player who can kick bags against us.

[Axe Man]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Jarrod Harbrow to get a farewell game this weekend which is a nice touch by the Suns since he hasn't played AFL since round 5.

[jazzadogs]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Jarrod Harbrow to get a farewell game this weekend which is a nice touch by the Suns since he hasn't played AFL since round 5.

Games record holder for the Suns, isn't he?

[EasternWest]

Re: Delisting and Retirements - 2021

Like most, I have no idea what he actually said, but.....

So we practice cancel culture, and send him packing forever for one thoughtless act. Let he who has not sinned cast the first stone.

I think most everybody knows what he said.

Also, "cancel culture" is possibly the worst modern day catchphrase ever created.

I just wouldn't want him because I think he's a spent force. He's played some good footy this year but he was racing to the cliff before it. I'd be worried he spent all his tickets this year finding some form.

Plus you know, the racist thing.