“too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

[angelopetraglia]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Doug Hawkins. Too funny. My childhood hero. What a legend. When players were real characters.

[Bulldog Joe]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

I love how Dougie managed to appear in almost every one even when he wasn't involved in the play!

Explains wht Dougie never won a Brownlow

[Bulldog4life]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Crazy dumb rule. Who's next the coaches then supporters? So ridiculous.

[Axe Man]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Crazy dumb rule. Who's next the coaches then supporters? So ridiculous.

Coaches and officials are already covered by the dissent rule and I don't have a problem with that. The players are playing a brutal game though and need to be cut some slack to respectfully question umpires and feel exasperation at times, that is not dissent.

[Happy Days]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Eddie McGuire just gave a completely unhinged 15 point solution (?) to whatever he believes the issue here to be on Footy Classified, which once again has me assuming this is less a real issue and more a content mine because no coach has been sacked yet and Essendon are shit.

The only real solution is to pay them more, which is the way that every other industry in the entire world attracts people to undesirable jobs.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Eddie McGuire just gave a completely unhinged 15 point solution (?) to whatever he believes the issue here to be on Footy Classified, which once again has me assuming this is less a real issue and more a content mine because no coach has been sacked yet and Essendon are shit.

The only real solution is to pay them more, which is the way that every other industry in the entire world attracts people to undesirable jobs.

Absolutely. I read at junior level it's 25-50 bucks for a game or something like that. Whatever it is, should be increased.
Bullying should be treated like any other workplace. If someone is demonstrative in the extreme, they get a warning.
If the player can't control themselves they should turn away from the umpire, or maintain some distance.
Poor language towards umpires, again, like any other workplace.

[Bulldog4life]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Coaches and officials are already covered by the dissent rule and I don't have a problem with that. The players are playing a brutal game though and need to be cut some slack to respectfully question umpires and feel exasperation at times, that is not dissent.

I was joking in my post however it will be interesting to see how many coaches throw their arms out when a free is given against their team. Chris Scott is a monty.

[Sedat]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Eddie McGuire just gave a completely unhinged 15 point solution

It is left-field but a number of the points he raised have merit.

The new dissent rule is akin to cracking a walnut with a sledgehammer. The AFEL have absolutely no nuance or feel for common sense.

[Grantysghost]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Coaches and officials are already covered by the dissent rule and I don't have a problem with that. The players are playing a brutal game though and need to be cut some slack to respectfully question umpires and feel exasperation at times, that is not dissent.

Spot on its so dystopian I'm at a loss to understand the logic.
You can be annoyed, exasperated, flummoxed, perplexed, straight up pissed at a decision and show emotion surely.

Psychologists will tell you there's an emotion - >behaviour pathway, as long as that behaviour is within reason it shouldn't be punished.

Holding out your arms in a questioning fashion is not unacceptable behaviour in any civilised society.

What are they smoking?

[Ghost Dog]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Spot on its so dystopian I'm at a loss to understand the logic.
You can be annoyed, exasperated, flummoxed, perplexed, straight up pissed at a decision and show emotion surely.

Psychologists will tell you there's an emotion - >behaviour pathway, as long as that behaviour is within reason it shouldn't be punished.

Holding out your arms in a questioning fashion is not unacceptable behaviour in any civilised society.

What are they smoking?

When you put it like that, it is really embarrassing. It makes the AFL look like a nanny state.

[Bornadog]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

When you put it like that, it is really embarrassing. It makes the AFL look like a nanny state.

AFL have lost the plot

[EasternWest]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Spot on its so dystopian I'm at a loss to understand the logic.
You can be annoyed, exasperated, flummoxed, perplexed, straight up pissed at a decision and show emotion surely.

Psychologists will tell you there's an emotion - >behaviour pathway, as long as that behaviour is within reason it shouldn't be punished.

Holding out your arms in a questioning fashion is not unacceptable behaviour in any civilised society.

What are they smoking?

I know that this is shifting the narrative a bit, but if the AFL really wanted to change something that just looks terrible, how about they stop the players spitting every three seconds?

Maybe I'm an old man with an onion tied to my belt yelling at clouds, but to me that's the most vile thing and just looks awful.

[Daughter of the West]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

Spot on its so dystopian I'm at a loss to understand the logic.
You can be annoyed, exasperated, flummoxed, perplexed, straight up pissed at a decision and show emotion surely.

Psychologists will tell you there's an emotion - >behaviour pathway, as long as that behaviour is within reason it shouldn't be punished.

Holding out your arms in a questioning fashion is not unacceptable behaviour in any civilised society.

What are they smoking?

I'm forever holding out my arms in a questioning fashion when arguing with my six year old, thank god we're not on a footy field together...

[Bornadog]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

I'm forever holding out my arms in a questioning fashion when arguing with my six year old, thank god we're not on a footy field together...

Does she give it back to you

[macca]

Re: “too big a penalty”: 50-metre chaos reigns in first sign of umpire abuse crackdown

I'm forever holding out my arms in a questioning fashion when arguing with my six year old, thank god we're not on a footy field together...

Is she giving you the dissent card ?