Delistings and Retirements 2022

[EasternWest]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Oscar was a waste of a list spot

Not enough red meat and manliness obviously.

[Happy Days]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Not enough red meat and manliness obviously.

Up yours woke moralists - we'll see who delists who

[Grantysghost]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Not enough red meat and manliness obviously.

If you're not eating a farm each week you're not an "old mcdonald".

[josie]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Serious Q woofers:
Is Oscar McDonald a better or worse defender and backup ruck than:
Keath this year
Cordy any year
Gardener in his first year
O’Brien this year
Bruce in defence in last game vs hawks

And what are knocks on him? Soft, slow, does not tackle, no footy IQ, cannot mark …..

[Mofra]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Mofra Sam Skinner has been delisted.

Port have also delisted Sam Mayes and Taj Schofield.

Sam Mayes might get a gig somewhere else under the 'Gorringe' rule
Skinner's injuries killed him. Poor kid

[Mofra]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Serious Q woofers:
Is Oscar McDonald a better or worse defender and backup ruck than:
Keath this year
Cordy any year
Gardener in his first year
O’Brien this year
Bruce in defence in last game vs hawks

And what are knocks on him? Soft, slow, does not tackle, no footy IQ, cannot mark …..

A less skilled Zaine Cordy with less mongrel.
A very very good state league KPD.

Not sure we need another entry in the Bulldogs dud-brother book of records

[josie]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

A less skilled Zaine Cordy with less mongrel.
A very very good state league KPD.

Not sure we need another entry in the Bulldogs dud-brother book of records

OK - that’s a pretty resounding nope!!

[Mofra]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Newnes was their fall guy this season, he would come in and play OK but quickly get dropped.
He did well to get to 200 games.

Good runner, disposal very hit or miss

[Axe Man]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Serious Q woofers:
Is Oscar McDonald a better or worse defender and backup ruck than:
Keath this year
Cordy any year
Gardener in his first year
O’Brien this year
Bruce in defence in last game vs hawks

And what are knocks on him? Soft, slow, does not tackle, no footy IQ, cannot mark …..

That Carlton are looking to strengthen their KPD stocks (linked to McAsey who has shown nothing in his career so far) should tell you all you need to know about McDonald.

[azabob]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

A few list changes out of the hawks.

Among them Liam Shiels has retired and Tom Phillips has been delisted. Phillips went from Collingwoods best team; to salary cap dump to delisted in a matter of a few of years.

[Bornadog]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

NORTH Melbourne has delisted Western Australian defender Kyron Hayden as well as Tasmanian duo Matt McGuinness and Patrick Walker ahead of next season.

[jazzadogs]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

A few list changes out of the hawks.

Among them Liam Shiels has retired and Tom Phillips has been delisted. Phillips went from Collingwoods best team; to salary cap dump to delisted in a matter of a few of years.

Is Phillips absolutely done? Was a very effective winger for Collingwood in his last two years there from memory - what caused the drop? Coaching? Injuries? Wonder if he'll get another club.

[GVGjr]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Is Phillips absolutely done? Was a very effective winger for Collingwood in his last two years there from memory - what caused the drop? Coaching? Injuries? Wonder if he'll get another club.

I seem to recall some decent games from Howe but he is out of favor as well. Not sure what happened with Phillips and as you say he was performing strongly for the Pies when he left.

[jazzadogs]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

I seem to recall some decent games from Howe but he is out of favor as well. Not sure what happened with Phillips and as you say he was performing strongly for the Pies when he left.

Howe is fine but 27 and a depth player, and has been on their list for a long time. Could definitely see him getting picked up by a club needing more depth - good gold coast/GWS/north candidate.

[DOG GOD]

Re: Delistings and Retirements 2022

Howe got best on ground the last time they thumped us at Launceston…the same game TOB took 14 or so marks as an interceptor lol
So having said that, we are probably looking at Howe