A room full of shovels, take your pick....

[Grantysghost]

You've got one choice. ONE.

ANY player in the AFL to come to the Dogs.

Who are you ripping away from their current club and slotting into the mighty West and why?

[Grantysghost]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

I'm going Andrew Brayshaw from Fremantle...I know I know we have other areas of need; it's just this kid ooooozes leadership. I watched him live and isolated him for a period and the work he does is second to none. He was involved in a contest, got knocked down, got back up tackled chased harrassed and if memory serves me correctly he won the ball back which ended in a scoring chain.


Skilled, durable hard worker who has leadership traits beyond his years. Sign me up!

[Sedat]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Tom Stewart or Sam DeKoning. We either get the best 3rd tall defender in the competition in his absolute prime, or the best emerging key defender in the competition with another 10+ years to go in his career.

[Bornadog]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Darcy Moore - backline would be bolstered and we become a premiership threat.

[The Doctor]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Charlie Cameron would complete our forward line nicely

[Happy Days]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

I mean the right answer is Steven May but I don’t think any of us actually want that.

I’d love Sam Taylor because Naughton is about the only player in the AFL capable of cooking him. He’d be unstoppable with us.

[chef]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

If it's just for this season give me Gawn, if it's for a career give me Jackson.

Our biggest hole now is a cracking number 1 ruck(who can actually ruck).

[1eyedog]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Tough choice. Cameron is getting old. I'd go Weitering.

[Sedat]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

I mean the right answer is Steven May but I don’t think any of us actually want that.

Yep, hence why I went for the more palatable (and much younger) version with DeKoning. May undeniably would be a gun in our team.

[Grantysghost]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Tom Stewart or Sam DeKoning. We either get the best 3rd tall defender in the competition in his absolute prime, or the best emerging key defender in the competition with another 10+ years to go in his career.

De Koning is a ripper, the Cats rarely miss do they and in terms of positional need he's perfect.

[Grantysghost]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Charlie Cameron would complete our forward line nicely

Does he stand up in big games our Charlie? I can't recall. That was legit question not a statement.

He's the type we are crying out for absolutely. Hopefully Clarke can be the man.

[Grantysghost]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

What about a small fast lockdown defender? Who springs to mind?

[Rocket Science]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Reckon Maynard would look alright in our colours.

[Grantysghost]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

Reckon Maynard would look alright in our colours.

Yes RS.

He's a beast.

[jazzadogs]

Re: A room full of shovels, take your pick....

If I was taking a ruckman, it's Sean Darcy over the others.

Like the suggestions of Maynard or De Koning.