2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

[Sedat]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Mike Pyke has a premiership medal, Chris Grant doesn't.

Life is cruel.

I appreciate your sentiment but I reckon Pyke deserves his premiership medal far more than Greg Madigan, Ben Marsh, Aaron Keating, Nathan Ablett, Aaron Shattock, Shannon Motlop, Shane Clayton, Paul Hills, etc..

[Remi Moses]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Well Hawthorn have a history of merging after only 5 years without a flag
Sydney's tackling 11th highest ever recorded!
Hawks kicking couldn't stand up under intense pressure.
Ryan O'keefe looked spent 12 months ago, I thought Hanneberry was sensational.
Credit to Sydney with guys like Morton and Pike terrific.( great coaching making Pike a credible player)Apparently Bolton had an ACL injury, so one brave effort.
Tackling and pressure won Sydney this flag.Hawks have to few do the heavy lifting.
Clinton Young the Athorn for mine, and that effort in the goal square resembled a 60 y/0 trying to pick the ball up.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Longmire's decision to take Mumford off was ballsy to say the least. Hale was having a big influence and to put his faith in a 100% fit Pyke to ruck out the final 25 minutes was a very brave call. And it delivered in spades because Sydney ran out the game stronger and Pyke was able to nullify Hale and Roughy at the stoppages in the last qtr.

To be honest, I thought this was an easy call.

Mumford was struggling whilst Pyke was playing and competing really well. Swans were desperate for some run, so replacing an injured lumbering tall was very clear cut.

Ballsy was to play Morton - and that definitely paid off!

[KT31]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Arguably the best grand final ever.

I respected Sydney before this as everyone else did, but that has just gone up ten fold. What an incredible team.

Better than 54 ?

[Dry Rot]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Goodes played on with a torn PCL - gutsy effort.

https://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/148845/default.aspx

[Remi Moses]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

I liked 89 personally.
But had to have had the most momentum swings in GF history this one.

[LostDoggy]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Mike Pyke has a premiership medal, Chris Grant doesn't.

Life is cruel.

The Swans since moving to Sydney have twice as many grand final appearances and twice as many premierships than the dogs.
Life is cruel.

WC 5 GFs 3 flags, Brisbane 4 & 3, Adelaide 2 & 2, even Port snuck one in the last 10yrs.
Life is cruel.

.......maybe it's not 'life' but being associated with the Western Bulldogs is cruel?

[Desipura]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Clay Smith is the type of player who would thrive playing in a grand final, nice and hard style footy. I hope he gets to play in at least one with us.

[LostDoggy]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Have to disagree on few views here.
A team of Clay Smith types who have great endeavor but can't kick will get us no where.
A balance of highly pace, skilled and hard at it types will go further.
Even Sydney has a few outside types.
Lewis Jetta and Mitch Morton do their roles well but I wouldn't call them courageous types.
Mummy was weak as pee yesterday.
Martin Pike before yesterday would jave struggled to get a game in many sides.

One other thing about the frees, I never at one stage thought the Swans were being hard done by.
It was the Swans that benefitted from an obvious non holding the ball against LRT in the second and goaled.
In the Jack goal, Young was weak and should never have gone to ground but Jack hands helped him a little. Sometimes given sometimes not.

[Mantis]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Mummy was weak as pee yesterday.

How was he as weak as piss? He was quite obviously playing injured and his performance suffered.

[LostDoggy]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

How was he as weak as piss? He was quite obviously playing injured and his performance suffered.

His ruck efforts were poor, his man who I wouldnt class as that good beat him in the air,ran off him and kicked goals. Only 6 possessions and beaten in the taps. Who knew he has injured at the time? Obvious afterwards. I bet there were others carrying injuries but played way better.

[AndrewP6]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Martin Pike before yesterday would jave struggled to get a game in many sides.
.

Mike Pyke?

[AndrewP6]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

His ruck efforts were poor, his man who I wouldnt class as that good beat him in the air,ran off him and kicked goals. Only 6 possessions and beaten in the taps. Who knew he has injured at the time? Obvious afterwards. I bet there were others carrying injuries but played way better.

Mumford had a sore hammy going in.

[Remi Moses]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

Mumford was clearly hampered by a hammy.
Pike's been well coached and has improved markedly.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: 2012 AFL Grand Final Thread

His ruck efforts were poor, his man who I wouldnt class as that good beat him in the air,ran off him and kicked goals. Only 6 possessions and beaten in the taps. Who knew he has injured at the time? Obvious afterwards. I bet there were others carrying injuries but played way better.

Jude Bolton had a leg amputated during the week and Adam Goodes had the vet come out with a screen at one point