AFL Round 15 Discussion

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Who is missing Eastdog? Haven't seen the game, picked em though so rather pissed off!

I tipped them too. They really have been beaten in defence. I think they had two defenders out.

[SlimPickens]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Should Matt Watson play, would that sure up their defence? As I said I'm not watching so don't know where they're struggling?

[DOG GOD]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I can see Carlton make a play for Tom Boyd...desperate for a fwd option considering Waite is always suspended or injured.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I can see Carlton make a play for Tom Boyd...desperate for a fwd option considering Waite is always suspended or injured.

It would be a feel good story for the club too as he supports them. But I'm not sure the players are on board with the plan, because their trade value is dropping each week.

[Remi Moses]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I wouldn't take anyone bar Kruezer from them .
Their pick is going to be higher than a lot of teams.
Thought Collingwoods leaders were terrific tonight .
Carlton are a bunch of front runners who have to many who play on their own terms

[bulldogtragic]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I wouldn't take anyone bar Kruezer from them .
Their pick is going to be higher than a lot of teams.
Thought Collingwoods leaders were terrific tonight .
Carlton are a bunch of front runners who have to many who play on their own terms

I think their season is a warning for us and Melbourne. You can have a heap of top 10 picks and a couple of guns, but if the players are not coached well over a decent period then watch out. Not even Malthouse can 'unlearn' these shocking team attributes. Going to be a fire sale at Carlton in 4 months!

[azabob]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I think their season is a warning for us and Melbourne. You can have a heap of top 10 picks and a couple of guns, but if the players are not coached well over a decent period then watch out. Not even Malthouse can 'unlearn' these shocking team attributes. Going to be a fire sale at Carlton in 4 months!

Interesting observation BT, very interesting indeed.

[Remi Moses]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

I think their season is a warning for us and Melbourne. You can have a heap of top 10 picks and a couple of guns, but if the players are not coached well over a decent period then watch out. Not even Malthouse can 'unlearn' these shocking team attributes. Going to be a fire sale at Carlton in 4 months!

Agree, that's why we should go nowhere near them.
I reckon they don't like Micks tough love

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Should Matt Watson play, would that sure up their defence? As I said I'm not watching so don't know where they're struggling?

There biggest problem is that the have too many midfielders and not enough KP players.

[Topdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

There biggest problem is that the have too many midfielders and not enough KP players.

Yet their midfield got smashed yesterday.

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Yet their midfield got smashed yesterday.

Compared to other teams who are now doing well they haven't done the best recruiting.

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

North carving up Richmond.

[Remi Moses]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Richmond won't win a final the way they play.
I'd back Port to knock them over the way they play.

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Richmond won't win a final the way they play.
I'd back Port to knock them over the way they play.

North could push close to the finals. It was there bad start that will come back to bite them.

[Eastdog]

Re: AFL Round 15 Discussion

Tipped the Cats tonight should be another ripper.