Cloke is not an elite player

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Cloke is not an elite player

Does that mean you don't class Nick Riewoldt as elite. His kicking at goal is also average.
Clokes field kicking is very good.

Am I wrong? Perhaps it would be trading on past credit to say Nick is elite these days. He misses some shockers. But is this just a perception? Of course all key fowards have some bad days. Part of that is he's so buggered half the time. But Nick's head-down over-the-leg and kick-without-looking technique I find a little baffling.

[mighty_west]

Re: Cloke is not an elite player

He falls just short of elite due to his dodgy kicking for goal IMO.

[mighty_west]

Re: Cloke is not an elite player

Does that mean you don't class Nick Riewoldt as elite. His kicking at goal is also average.
Clokes field kicking is very good.

I'd have Nick slightly falling short of elite due to his kicking for goal, stage diving and crying like a little baby.

[Topdog]

Re: Cloke is not an elite player

If Riewoldt is not elite there are no elite forwards in the game and haven't been since Carey.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Cloke is not an elite player

Maybe we could get Liam Jones listed as elite…