halftime scrap

[Doc26]

Re: halftime scrap

This was the best melee v Saints

https://youtu.be/oS3S3icYgdY

Is this the melee where Shaggy broke Heath Black's jaw ?

[Bornadog]

Re: halftime scrap

Is this the melee where Shaggy broke Heath Black's jaw ?

Yes right at the end of the video.

[Happy Days]

Re: halftime scrap

Yes right at the end of the video.

He only got 1 week for that.

How did he only get 1 week for that??

[G-Mo77]

Re: halftime scrap

I remember that well. Black actually got up and went after Nathan Brown. He probably only remembered the blonde hair so went for the closest one.

[Topdog]

Re: halftime scrap

I don't know much of the guys character. But he is a captain of a footy club. His recent personal battles lately with family. I very much doubt he would have said anything about clays knee. Most footy players, even opposing team players would feel bad about that injury occurring. Such a shame for clay. Ome of my favourite players. I hope the doc offers LARS. Might just work for him. Hope he gets back. He loves the game too much to give up without the doc telling him he needs to

An ex-Bulldog player certainly believes that Nick made a comment about Clay to start it all.

[Go_Dogs]

Re: halftime scrap

An ex-Bulldog player certainly believes that Nick made a comment about Clay to start it all.

Are you able to elaborate?

[Missing-Dog]

Re: halftime scrap

Is this the melee where Shaggy broke Heath Black's jaw ?

Shaggy could go with his fists. ITRC Aaron Hamill had a fair bit to do with regards to starting that. If ever there was anyone to fit the "Looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane" description, it was Hamill.

[I'm Not Bitter Anymore!]

Re: halftime scrap

Shaggy could go with his fists. ITRC Aaron Hamill had a fair bit to do with regards to starting that. If ever there was anyone to fit the "Looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane" description, it was Hamill.

He did his knee when he kneed someone in a pack which was poetic justice

[1eyedog]

Re: halftime scrap

Shaggy could go with his fists. ITRC Aaron Hamill had a fair bit to do with regards to starting that. If ever there was anyone to fit the "Looks like Tarzan, plays like Jane" description, it was Hamill.

Not sure about this, at least from a footballing perspective. Hamill played the game pretty hard, not sure what he was like when you fronted up to him but I remember many injuries and times out of the game because he threw his body around. I remember him going pretty hard on one of the Scott's too when they were bumping Crywoldt after he put his shoulder out.

[Twodogs]

Re: halftime scrap

I thought Hamill played the game hard but I remeber the knee thing IMB mentioned. He was the first player I remember being exchanged for draft picks. Carlton got St Kildas pick 4 and a second round pick. No player or money went to them and it seemed like St Kilda had made out like bandits, Carlton made out they were a bit miffed they hadn't got a player in exchange. Not many people really understood the concept of drafting and the value of early picks back then.

I wonder who Carlton picked with their abstract new draft picks?

[Happy Days]

Re: halftime scrap

I thought Hamill played the game hard but I remeber the knee thing IMB mentioned. He was the first player I remember being exchanged for draft picks. Carlton got St Kildas pick 4 and a second round pick. No player or money went to them and it seemed like St Kilda had made out like bandits, Carlton made out they were a bit miffed they hadn't got a player in exchange. Not many people really understood the concept of drafting and the value of early picks back then.

I wonder who Carlton picked with their abstract new draft picks?

I know one of the players was Luke "next SOS" Livingston, so maybe St Kilda did make out like bandits?

[Axe Man]

Re: halftime scrap

I thought Hamill played the game hard but I remeber the knee thing IMB mentioned. He was the first player I remember being exchanged for draft picks. Carlton got St Kildas pick 4 and a second round pick. No player or money went to them and it seemed like St Kilda had made out like bandits, Carlton made out they were a bit miffed they hadn't got a player in exchange. Not many people really understood the concept of drafting and the value of early picks back then.

I wonder who Carlton picked with their abstract new draft picks?

Hamill was traded for pick 4 and Sam Cranage (whoever he was). As Happy Days said pick 4 turned out to be Luke Livingston, but in fairness to Carlton it was a pretty crappy draft.

[Missing-Dog]

Re: halftime scrap

Not sure about this, at least from a footballing perspective. Hamill played the game pretty hard, not sure what he was like when you fronted up to him but I remember many injuries and times out of the game because he threw his body around. I remember him going pretty hard on one of the Scott's too when they were bumping Crywoldt after he put his shoulder out.

good at throwing his weight around, that's about it. extremely overrated.

[G-Mo77]

Re: halftime scrap

We'll never known if Riewoldt said anything or not but I do believe in karma.

[Mantis]

Re: halftime scrap

We'll never known if Riewoldt said anything or not but I do believe in karma.

Crude!