Jack Redpath

[Bornadog]

Re: Jack Redpath

The club absolutely needs to challenge this one.

We continually roll over to rubbish MRP assessments and it just must stop.

[Twodogs]

Re: Jack Redpath

Davis must have a sharp tongue on the field....plenty of forwards have been fined or suspended punching him clearly in retaliation to something.

He's a sniper with a punchable head. Opponents with punchable heads are dangerous things.

One of my old coaches in juniors told my biggest advantage in football was my "supremely punchable head"

[always right]

Re: Jack Redpath

According to Murph's press conference, we are challenging Redpath's suspension.

[Bornadog]

Re: Jack Redpath

According to Murph's press conference, we are challenging Redpath's suspension.

So we should. When is a push with open hand reportable?. Not even in the rule book

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Jack Redpath

Found guilty and gets 3 weeks.

What a *!*!*!*!ing joke the AFL has become. Wines gets off, Greene gets off, Houli gets 4 for a legit punch and Redpath 3 for a open handed push. Disgraceful.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Jack Redpath

They have lost the plot. And they're losing me

[KT31]

Re: Jack Redpath

@$@?ing joke !!!

[Eastdog]

Re: Jack Redpath

Unfair Jack doesn't deserve 3 weeks for that.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Jack Redpath

To be honest i really don't know why we appealed. Yep it was a ridiculous charge, but when you see what others are going for with the revised rules around striking i really am staggered we bothered.

[kruder]

Re: Jack Redpath

As expected sums up our year really. I hope it isn't the last time we see big red in the bulldogs colours while he has limitations he is one of the few natural forwards on our list.

[Bulldog4life]

Re: Jack Redpath

When is a push far worse than a kick in the face?When you play in the AFL.

[Eastdog]

Re: Jack Redpath

When is a push far worse than a kick in the face?When you play in the AFL.

Just doesn't make sense.

[Bornadog]

Re: Jack Redpath

To be honest i really don't know why we appealed. Yep it was a ridiculous charge, but when you see what others are going for with the revised rules around striking i really am staggered we bothered.

I am glad we appealed as we didn't just take it up the cracker like we have in the past. Nobody can stand back and accept something like that. I wonder if we can challenge even further, some how. Perhaps in a law court, as this is ridiculous, it is something that happens a hundred times a game. The number of times JJ copped it this year and no one was reported if that is what they think.

The tribunal, the MRP and the whole AFL have losted it, especially this year. I am just flabbergasted with the events this week.

[Rocket Science]

Re: Jack Redpath

Somewhere, Trent Cotchin is sitting quietly chuckling to himself.

[AndrewP6]

Re: Jack Redpath

And they say they want to battle the game of soccer to keep people interested in our game. FFS. A push with an open hand is seen to be worse than kicking someone in the face. I don't know. I'm just about done.