Our 5 best players?

[ratsmac]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Liam Picken was our Stuart Dew on grand final day

[Twodogs]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Liam Picken was our Stuart Dew on grand final day

Except Picko played 4 quarters on Gf day as opposed to half a quarter.

[MrMahatma]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Liam Picken was our Stuart Dew on grand final day

He was the player of the finals series. Much more than a burst player.

[always right]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Best?

Bontempelli
Stringer
Toyd
Liberatore
Dahlhaus

Or most vital to us?

Bontempelli
Liberatore
Wood
Dahlhaus
Johannisen

Is Toyd's inclusion based on potential? I would find it impossible to include him based on one performance no matter how good it was.

My top 5;
Bont
Dahl
Libba
Wood
JJ

[soupman]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Is Toyd's inclusion based on potential? I would find it impossible to include him based on one performance no matter how good it was.

Can't see Toyd in the top 5. I have 14 clearly ahead of, and he sits in a bracket that contains about 5 other players. He was awesome in the GF, but you could argue Clay Smith was just as influential in the PF. Potentially he could be top 5, but I'd want to see a good run of form before putting him ahead of Bont, Moyd, Dahl, Hunter, Stringer, Wood and Morris just for starters.

[KT31]

Re: Our 5 best players?

My top 5 as of typing - ( but gee I've chopped and changed a few times in the last hour)

Bonts
Dahl
Libba
Wood
Macrae

[Twodogs]

Re: Our 5 best players?

My top 5 as of typing - ( but gee I've chopped and changed a few times in the last hour)

Bonts
Dahl
Libba
Wood
Macrae

That's top quality but I'd like to see one of our talls push into that group by year's end.

[whythelongface]

Re: Our 5 best players?

My top 5 as of typing - ( but gee I've chopped and changed a few times in the last hour)

Bonts
Dahl
Libba
Wood
Macrae

Pretty much mine as well. Only change would be in the order with Wood pushing up to # 2 followed by Dahl, Libba and Macrae. Morris would be just behind them.

[Twodogs]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Pretty much mine as well. Only change would be in the order with Wood pushing up to # 2 followed by Dahl, Libba and Macrae. Morris would be just behind them.

The only other player I have to add to KT's list would be JJ.

[stefoid]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Sorry...

geez, Boyd has a touch of the Ivan Dragos in that photo - "I must break you"

[Eastdog]

Re: Our 5 best players?

This is really tough but I'll have a go:

1. Bont
2. Libba
3. Wood
4. JJ
5. Picken

Morris, Murph, Wallis, T Boyd, Macrae all unlucky but like ratsmac said this for me I reckon can change day by day.

Revised:

1. Bonti
2. Dahl
3. Libba
4. JJ
5. Picken

Wish I could fit in Morris, Wood, Wallis, Macrae, T Boyd - will become very important

Dunks and Zaine Cordy huge potential to get into that list

Unbelievable I didnt have Dahl in my first list!

How about Biggs and Roughy? I reckon they are both important players.

[Eastdog]

Re: Our 5 best players?

Liam Picken was our Stuart Dew on grand final day

Just a great worker. You will always get pretty much 100% out of Picko.

[Eastdog]

Re: Our 5 best players?

My top 5 as of typing - ( but gee I've chopped and changed a few times in the last hour)

Bonts
Dahl
Libba
Wood
Macrae

Yes its extremely tough doing a top 5.

[Mantis]

Re: Our 5 best players?

That's top quality but I'd like to see one of our talls push into that group by year's end.

Who would be most likely?

FWIW I wouldn't have a tall in the top 10-15 so they are coming from a long way back.

[1eyedog]

Re: Our 5 best players?

geez, Boyd has a touch of the Ivan Dragos in that photo - "I must break you"

Yep staring directly at GWS' list manager!