Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

[Doc26]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Can someone clarify how the mark rule is interrupted on that one ?
T.boyd gets first one hand ball falls forwRd in air and another Richmond player touches it and tTom gets it in second attempt with a lovely twist. ON first sight it looked like a good mark , but replay showed Richmond player may got a fair bit of it and tom not in cit Byron on the first touch.

I agree that at first sight it appeared a good grab by TBoyd. On this occasion the umpire made a good call given Grimes made the second touch without Boydy's hand on the ball.

[always right]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

I like your list although I did feel that Grimes did get the second touch with the TBoyd mark that you refer to.
Lin did work very hard around the midfield contests when the Tigers had the ascendancy.

Haven't seen the replay of the Boyd mark. Watching live I though his opponent held him by the arm anyway.

[westbulldog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

B
Adams - if he keeps up this form he will be invaluable.
Dalhaus - has to be leading the B & F at this stage.
Murphy - crucial possessions when it counted

allow me a fourth - Toby Greene sulking in the stand watching the plastics get whacked.

A
Inaccuracy
Injuries
Slow starts

[macca]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

1.Adams second goal and mark with 20 sec to go wonderful contested mark
2. . Some of the handballs in congestion by Bonts was breathtaking his little on the ground kick in last quarter was amazing . Martin is a beast and how he beat wood and Zaine in the duel in the last quarter was man possessed

3. Dalhaus- tries his heart out and he was everywhere
4. Daniel: gee he took some good overhead marks in the last. Knows how to find the ball and get though the congestion .
5. Manic pressure is back . HArdwick acknowledged that in press conference

Interesting post match conference Bevo answering : Boyd is a ruckman who can play forward.
We need to get more games into Williams , he can play , nice size and needs to take the first option. LUcky to get that free in the last when he turned into the tackle. He missed the first handball option.

Was fletcher moved foward in last few minutes?
anchor:
1. Injuries: is it time to bring back the sub player? Not only our games but teams are Losing players to injuries every game. Stringer and Vlaustin. Adam Kennedy went down with knee injury in first quarter . We lost players to impact injuries icken to concussion , Lina and Cloke . Pace of game is very fast and high impact

2. Umpires- missed a few high ones in the last but will take the dumb riewold frees in the last

[Eastdog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Bankers

Clay Smith - Kicked some good goals

Easton Wood - Took some fantastic marks in defence

Marcus Adams - Critical initially with him being up there but he did good took some marks and kicked goals


Anchors

Hunter - Gets a lot of it and involved but not so good with the efficiency

Giving the opposition an early jump on us in the 1st quarter

Some of our turnovers very frustrating

[hujsh]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Can someone clarify how the mark rule is interrupted on that one ?
T.boyd gets first one hand ball falls forwRd in air and another Richmond player touches it and tTom gets it in second attempt with a lovely twist. ON first sight it looked like a good mark , but replay showed Richmond player may got a fair bit of it and tom not in control of the first touch.

Both Boyd and the Richmond player touched the ball at the same time on the second Boyd touch. Technically not a mark but usually would be paid.

[Danny the snakeman]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Both Boyd and the Richmond player touched the ball at the same time on the second Boyd touch. Technically not a mark but usually would be paid.

I would not of said at same time, Rich guy had clear 2nd touch.

[merantau]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Bankers
1. When the whips were cracking we didn't crack.
2. Bontempelli - the Real McCoy
3. Adams - very good game

Anchors
1. Goal kicking - Dicko we need you
2. Kicking inside 50 - very sloppy
3. My jangled nervous system - that late Richmond goal took years off my life.

[The Underdog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

I would not of said at same time, Rich guy had clear 2nd touch.

The same ruling worked in our favour in the GF so I'm happy to cop this one

[SonofScray]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Banker:
1. Caleb Daniel's composed use of the ball through the middle and his ability to work in incredibly congested spaces. He is the Ant Man.

2. Handballing through traffic late. Boyd and Bont cut them to ribbons when we had to press the pace.

3. Marcus Adams. Some great moments in the game. Probably the match winner in the end.

Anchors:

Boyd's 1st shot. OOTF.
DAHL's kicking inside 50
Slow start

[Bornadog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Haven't seen the replay of the Boyd mark. Watching live I though his opponent held him by the arm anyway.

Typical Rance holding his opponent. Gets away with it every week. Should have been a free kick.

[Bornadog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

2. Umpires- missed a few high ones in the last but will take the dumb riewold frees in the last

I thought he let his team down giving away at least three silly frees by trying to take spectacular marks when he went up early.

[Ozza]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Bankers

Bontempelli - I've seen some champions for the Dogs over 38 years, but none, and I mean none inhabit the realm that Marcus lives in. He's almost more than a once in a generation player.
Bailey Williams - this kid just needs to play more games of football. He's a gem. The position and role he plays means he will make mistakes. But he's almost the re-signing we most need to happen this year, marginally behind JJ.
The ability of our coaching team to not only change tactics but also our 22 players to be able to take in and adopt those tactical changes.

Anchors
Our tactical decision to go small in the ruck as a second change. It nearly cost us tonight.
Matty Boyd - I hope I am proved wrong for posting during our poorest of moments tonight that he was cooked. But gees he was as bad as I've seen in 3 years tonight.
Dunkley He's going to play 200 games, hopefully all for us, and I am really saddened by his injury. However he really needs to improve his ball use.

**** Murph was almost my 3rd banker, saved by at least his impetus in taking the game on.
Hunter's 4th Qtr was fantastic, but his preceding 3 Qtrs stank like a stale fart in an elevator.

Interested in your comments on Matthew Boyd YHF.
I'm curious as to whether you watched the game live, or on TV?

[dukedog]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

Both Boyd and the Richmond player touched the ball at the same time on the second Boyd touch. Technically not a mark but usually would be paid.

I believe a couple of weeks ago. Cameron ling said live on tv that 'he had enough of it for mine.' Cordy actually got first punch on the ball. Ling still said it was good enough. My interpretation of the mark rule is that if u get first hands and finish it there after its a mark. I think even players past and present are unsure. Boyds was a clear mark. Someone tell me in past years where it wouldnt have been payed. AFEL making a mockery of rules this year. Dont even get me started on the 'intent rule' deliberate our of bounds. Richo and darce said someone gained an extra 30m on a kick. Well why comment on that when a guy can kick out of mid air 50m or fumble the ball over the line and be pinged. Absolute joke. Just make the rule last to touch it and be done with it. Its too hard to adjudicate as it is now.

[Ozza]

Re: Bankers And Anchors - Round 7, 2017 vs Richmond

How would Boyd's be a mark if the Richmond player touched it second?

Correct call was made. Sorry.