Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Apart from Wights absolute howler in the first quarter he actually played very well, and took a sensational mark in the centre square in the last quarter

Williams was nowhere near as good as Wight. I think whilst Wight makes mistakes he is making progress.

I thought Wight really struggled. It takes a fair level on incompetence these days to make Chris Tarrant look good.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

I thought Wight really struggled. It takes a fair level on incompetence these days to make Chris Tarrant look good.

Wight wasn't on him the whole time, and I didn't really think Tarrant looked good, ok maybe he looked good - you'd have to as BBelle to be sure, but I didn't really think he played that well or had a big influence on things.

[Bornadog]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

I thought Wight really struggled. It takes a fair level on incompetence these days to make Chris Tarrant look good.

Tarrant got some lucky goals. Williams gave away a stupid free kick behind the goals, Tarrant got a lucky soccer goal and can't remember the other two.

Overall both Williams and Wight made a few mistakes in the first quarter, but they stuck to their task.

[Desipura]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Tarrant got some lucky goals. Williams gave away a stupid free kick behind the goals, Tarrant got a lucky soccer goal and can't remember the other two.

Overall both Williams and Wight made a few mistakes in the first quarter, but they stuck to their task.

Credit where credit is due, Wight took a telling mark in the dying minutes of the game on the wing/half fwd flank for us.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

I bet if Williams had been playing all season then he wouldn't be making the same mistakes Wight does now.
So apart from 1 mark what did Wight actually do?
Williams made mistakes but a lot of those were in trying to create play.

I agree with Scooters thoughts on Tarrant.

[Bornadog]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Credit where credit is due, Wight took a telling mark in the dying minutes of the game on the wing/half fwd flank for us.

Wight will end up as a winger and rotate off the bench when Williams is firing and the match ups aren't there for the extra tall.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Tarrant got some lucky goals. Williams gave away a stupid free kick behind the goals, Tarrant got a lucky soccer goal and can't remember the other two.

Overall both Williams and Wight made a few mistakes in the first quarter, but they stuck to their task.

Tarrant also missed two when he could have put the game to bed.

[Bornadog]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Tarrant also missed two when he could have put the game to bed.

but didn't

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

but didn't

He could have missed the two 'lucky' ones he got as well.

But didn't.

[camwoof]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

I think Williams certianly looked a little underdone and his decision making was not the best. He will be better for the run though.

[ledge]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Wight will end up as a winger and rotate off the bench when Williams is firing and the match ups aren't there for the extra tall.

If Eade wants a winger he will play Farren there before Wight.

[GVGjr]

Re: Callan Out Williams In For Freo Clash

Apart from Wights absolute howler in the first quarter he actually played very well, and took a sensational mark in the centre square in the last quarter

Williams was nowhere near as good as Wight. I think whilst Wight makes mistakes he is making progress.

I tend to agree with this but Wight might be under a bit of pressure especially with some of the big tasks coming up soon.