Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

[Scraggers]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

In Schache or Boyd Lipinski Lynch
out Young Gowers Dickson

Yep ... This is what I would do; preferring Schache over Boyd

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

In: Lipsinki, Dale, Roberts
Out: Dickson, Gowers, Lachie Young

- Dickson and Gowers offer so little pressure wise and not much offensively. Simply have to go. Gowers seems to be a favourite of Bevo's...
- Lipsinki one of our better VFL players week in/week out. Needs to get a game.
- Hopefully Dale adds a bit of class forward, couldn't be much worse...
- I like Lachie Young but doesn't add to the team enough. Can't have him and Wood. I'd give Fletch a final go, has been decent enough in VFL.

[Smads57]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Having watched the magoos....no change.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Out : Dickson, Dunkley
In : Boyd, West.

Dicko and Gowers too similar I just think Billy is more dynamic although it's a coin toss , but Dicko is maybe close to the end.
Boyd in, pinch in the ruck Trengove permanent back.
Dunkley just needs to work on his disposal. West looked composed and I think would be a good time to debut him.

I haven't looked at match ups to be fair but just on personnel I'd do this.

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

I think we need to replace a couple of forwards with at least a tall and a small.

In:

Schache - even though he probably doesn't deserve it , but could be a good in against Tigers.
Lipinski

Out: Gowers, and Dickson

[Hotdog60]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

I think we need to replace a couple of forwards with at least a tall and a small.

In:

Schache - even though he probably doesn't deserve it , but could be a good in against Tigers.
Lipinski

Out: Gowers, and Dickson

I would have gone with Schache but on todays performance it would be rewarding for playing poorly.
It really hard because no one put there hand up to be selected.
Can we go unchanged with the warning that those players are in the firing line if they don't improve.

[whythelongface]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Do we bring in either Roberts or Lewis Young and try Trengove forward (again). Sure it hasn't worked in the past but at least he will make a contest. Drop either Dickson or Gowers. It is hard to make changes if no one is really putting up their hand in the magoos.

The other in should be Lipinski (based on reports). Probably drop Dunkley who, for mine, has been disappointing (I expected big things from him this year).

[1eyedog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Do we bring in either Roberts or Lewis Young and try Trengove forward (again). Sure it hasn't worked in the past but at least he will make a contest. Drop either Dickson or Gowers. It is hard to make changes if no one is really putting up their hand in the magoos.

The other in should be Lipinski (based on reports). Probably drop Dunkley who, for mine, has been disappointing (I expected big things from him this year).

No we bring in Schache and play a forward forward.

[whythelongface]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

No we bring in Schache and play a forward forward.

Problem is that Schache is not really up to it as shown by his last two senior performances (and going by today's report). Yes of course would love to see him play forward once his form warrants it. My thinking with Trengove is at least he will make a contest and be hard at it, something that Schache currently lacks.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

No we bring in Schache and play a forward forward.

And bring Roberts in as a back. My reports from a friend was he played quite well and one of the few who wasn't a call up

[MrMahatma]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Bevo’s presser seemed to focus on mid/small forwards. I’d expect some changes there.

Out: Gowers, Dickson, Dunkley, Lachlan Young
In: Lippinski, Shache, Dale, Lewis Young

Shache may be struggling but we need a better structure. Boyd needs match fitness but hopefully only a couple of weeks away.

[Danjul]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Do we bring in either Roberts or Lewis Young and try Trengove forward (again). Sure it hasn't worked in the past but at least he will make a contest. Drop either Dickson or Gowers. It is hard to make changes if no one is really putting up their hand in the magoos.

The other in should be Lipinski (based on reports). Probably drop Dunkley who, for mine, has been disappointing (I expected big things from him this year).

Dunkley 24 disposals, Richards 12.

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Dunkley 24 disposals, Richards 12.

I thought it was Dunkley's best game this year, although the goal he missed was atrocious.

[Nuggety Back Pocket]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

Problem is that Schache is not really up to it as shown by his last two senior performances (and going by today's report). Yes of course would love to see him play forward once his form warrants it. My thinking with Trengove is at least he will make a contest and be hard at it, something that Schache currently lacks.

The extreme windy conditions today made it extremely difficult for a leading forward like Schache to succeed. Boyd also struggled today. On the other hand both Webb and Dale did well. At the moment we do not have an effective key forward. Schache isn’t strong overhead but leads and kicks well. We need players who are able to be able to dispose of the ball correctly by foot and so play to his strengths.

[Scraggers]

Re: Always Right Match Committee - R7, Vs Richmond

The extreme windy conditions today made it extremely difficult for a leading forward like Schache to succeed. Boyd also struggled today. On the other hand both Webb and Dale did well. At the moment we do not have an effective key forward. Schache isn’t strong overhead but leads and kicks well. We need players who are able to be able to dispose of the ball correctly by foot and so play to his strengths.

I only watched the second half (online). Neither Schache or Boyd did enough to deserve a call up, but we need one of them. Given our current position, I would rather put game time into Schache than Boyd.