Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

[Happy Days]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

I really think saying we're a better side without Daniel because we beat the Dons by 100 points is putting 2 and 2 together to get 5. He's been fantastic this year.

I will however acknowledge that we've looked a far better side with Duryea on the field.

[Bullies]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

I really think saying we're a better side without Daniel because we beat the Dons by 100 points is putting 2 and 2 together to get 5. He's been fantastic this year.

I will however acknowledge that we've looked a far better side with Duryea on the field.

I haven't seen anyone say we are better without him in the side only that we seem to function better with him not in the back line. He certainly plays in any side we put out on the park.

[ratsmac]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Interesting call on Daniel. I agree that he should be further up the ground. There is no doubt he has been good in the backline. He gets us out of trouble so much but he is known for a couple of howlers a game. I don't like him taking the kick ins because he doesn't get enough distance on his kick. I can't understand why Suckling isn't the designated kicker. He puts it in the centre of the ground!

IMO Daniel would be better used on a wing. He has a super tank so he'll be up and down the ground much like Hunter. The small forwards would love his ability to find the non obvious target.

[Mantis]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

I really think saying we're a better side without Daniel because we beat the Dons by 100 points is putting 2 and 2 together to get 5. He's been fantastic this year.

I will however acknowledge that we've looked a far better side with Duryea on the field.

For a side that relies on fast ball movement Caleb's indecisiveness with ball in hand halts our momentum more than we would like.

[ledge]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Interesting call on Daniel. I agree that he should be further up the ground. There is no doubt he has been good in the backline. He gets us out of trouble so much but he is known for a couple of howlers a game. I don't like him taking the kick one because he doesn't get enough distance on his kick. I can't understand why Suckling isn't the designated kicker. He puts it in the centre of the ground!

IMO Daniel would be better used on a wing. He has a super tank so he'll be up and down the ground much like Hunter. The small forwards would love his ability to find the non obvious target.

I agree he seems to be able to hit up targets and that would improve our forward line no end.

[Bornadog]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

For a side that relies on fast ball movement Caleb's indecisiveness with ball in hand halts our momentum more than we would like.

Is it indecisiveness or he is looking for the best option?

[Mantis]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Is it indecisiveness or he is looking for the best option?

Whatever it is it allows the opposition to push back which makes it harder for the next kicker to find an option.

[ledge]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Whatever it is it allows the opposition to push back which makes it harder for the next kicker to find an option.

But if we move him up the ground a little and he hits forwards on the chest instead of wingers it doesn’t matter as they are close enough to have a shot.

[The bulldog tragician]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Is it indecisiveness or he is looking for the best option?

He is not a penetrating kick so he stops and looks for a safe option. I love him but I’m not a real fan of him in the backline especially when we kick backwards to use him.

[kruder]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

Good discussion re Daniel agree about the ball movement(should not be aloud to kick out also) but he is also poor one on one defending even against a small. There is also an issue when it's his turn to come across and help, he was ok at it the start of the year but has been poor for awhile now. We are already undersized in defence and need players like Crozier, Duryea, Wood,Suckling to come across and help out.

You really notice the difference when Duryea is playing a similar role, has really surprised me he is much better in the air and can come across and cover more effectively. Generally uses it well too.


Caleb could play the Hayes role from the weekend effectively.

[1eyedog]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

1. Looks like another flag this year Woofers.

2. Hayes played well so eating my words. Hopefully he can maintain the rage.

3. Schache has turned into a tough bastard. It's a thing of beauty he's gone from flaky soap to a real contested key forward. Man crush.

[westbulldog]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

re : Good discussion re Daniel agree about the ball movement(should not be aloud to kick out also) if I compare Caleb's dinky kicks out to those of Shannon Hurn and Lewis Jetta for example, there is light years difference. With the new rules the kick out can and should be a weapon and we are missing out.

[The Doctor]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

1. AFL - Western Bulldogs 21.11.137 def Essendon 4.9.33

2. VFL - Footscray Bulldogs 20.9.129 def Essendon 5.5.35

3. VFLW - Western Bulldogs 6.11.47 def Essendon 0.3.3

Doesn't get much better than that

[whythelongface]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

1. AFL - Western Bulldogs 21.11.137 def Essendon 4.9.33

2. VFL - Footscray Bulldogs 20.9.129 def Essendon 5.5.35

3. VFLW - Western Bulldogs 6.11.47 def Essendon 0.3.3

Doesn't get much better than that

Nope it sure doesn't. The only thing that would beat this if all these games were Grand Finals.

[AshMac]

Re: Three things you have learned-round 21 v Essendon 2019

1. It’s really hard to judge where we’re at playing a team as dreadful as essendon on Saturday
2. Our midfield is a taggers nightmare - without dunks hitting elite numbers weekly the combo of Macrae, bont and dunkley must be terrifying
3. loved bailey smiths tackle on Stringer in the second quarter - so strong