Cooney vs Judd 2008

[Throughandthrough]

Cooney


12 games 308 disposals 18 goals 31 tackles 3 HO


Judd


12 games 294 disposals 9 goals 40 tackles 0 ho

[LostDoggy]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Jeez, Judd is having a better season then I thought. Judd's 3rd for clearances(Cooney 10th) and 2nd for most for contested possessions (Cooney not in the top 45)

[Throughandthrough]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Where is Cooney in handball's received?


Top 5 i presume?

[Mofra]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

1 of those hitouts was a boundary throw in last week when he was the genuine ruckman (not a 3rd man up). As was his centre HO vs Cox.

Judd isn't as potent if/when resting the forward line however his in-close ability is phenominal

[Scorlibo]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Cooney not in the top 45 in contested possessions?? Thats very surprising. Cooney is a much better player than Judd this year, but if Judd were with us as opposed to Carlton then they would probably be level.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Wow..i read a thing in the paper about Judd playing as good as 2006..

Dont think he's gunna be in Brownlow top 5 or anythin though..

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Wow..i read a thing in the paper about Judd playing as good as 2006..

Dont think he's gunna be in Brownlow top 5 or anythin though..

Don't think he will play as long as coons ether

[Mantis]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Jeez, Judd is having a better season then I thought. Judd's 3rd for clearances(Cooney 10th) and 2nd for most for contested possessions (Cooney not in the top 45)

Didn't believe this so I just had a look on the afl website:

Contested Possessions (Top 10):

Chris Judd - 138
Gary Ablett (jnr) - 124
Simon Black - 122
Luke Ball - 119
Nathan Foley - 115
Adam Cooney - 112
Luke Power - 110
Shane O'Bree - 106
Aaron Sandilands - 104
Daniel Cross - 104

Now I know the afl website a big pile of poo, but they couldn't have it this wrong??

[LostDoggy]

Re: Cooney vs Judd 2008

Didn't believe this so I just had a look on the afl website:

Contested Possessions (Top 10):

Chris Judd - 138
Gary Ablett (jnr) - 124
Simon Black - 122
Luke Ball - 119
Nathan Foley - 115
Adam Cooney - 112
Luke Power - 110
Shane O'Bree - 106
Aaron Sandilands - 104
Daniel Cross - 104

Now I know the afl website a big pile of poo, but they couldn't have it this wrong??

I got my stats here.



http://www.pro-stats.com.au/psw/web/player_rankings?yr=2008&sp=SE&rt=LT&fc=E6

There's a big difference between the two sites. They must have differing opinions on what a contested ball is.

Judd = 68 Contested possies = 2nd place
Cooney = 30 = and is outside the top 45