WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

[Bornadog]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

On any measure. Impossible to defend Bruce’s game tonight.

and I am not defending him that is for sure.

He was rubbish tonight and I am beginning to wonder if we made a blunder in recruitment.

[Bornadog]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

JJ very emotional after the game

[angelopetraglia]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

and I am not defending him that is for sure.

He was rubbish tonight and I am beginning to wonder if we made a blunder in recruitment.

It’s difficult to judge on a season that is just crazy by any measure. But the key stats don’t look good for him.

-11 goals in 10 games (six of those in a single game).
-3.3 kicks per game average
-2.2 marks per game average

[Bornadog]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

It’s difficult to judge on a season that is just crazy by any measure. But the key stats don’t look good for him.

-11 goals in 10 games (six of those in a single game).
-3.3 kicks per game average
-2.2 marks per game average

He was the 5th highest contested mark last year. He is over weight, can't jump anymore and out of form. I will give him one thing, he is not lazy and doesn't lack effort, gives 100% but it is not working for him.

[Sedat]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

JJ very emotional after the game

Bevo in his presser very pointedly made a reference to the JJ handball howler late in the 2nd qtr completely changing momentum of the game. I wonder if he gave JJ a big cook after the game that resulted in this outpouring of emotion.

[Danjul]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

and I am not defending him that is for sure.

He was rubbish tonight and I am beginning to wonder if we made a blunder in recruitment.

Bruce is a distraction.

How is it the forward line can’t kick goals? Because there is no coordination between the forwards , or between the midfield and the forwards.

So what has to change? The way the ball is kicked and where it’s kicked. Also, how often it’s kicked.

Then give each player a specific role based on their talent. For example, Dale has never been a play maker. His talent is to find space, receive the ball and kick goals from 35-45 metres. That gives 20 goals in 5 games. But we have played him in a way that might give an occasional goal.

We have only one player who can make a goal out of nothing and that’s Wallis. The rest have to be used better.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

It’s difficult to judge on a season that is just crazy by any measure. But the key stats don’t look good for him.

-11 goals in 10 games (six of those in a single game).
-3.3 kicks per game average
-2.2 marks per game average

He kicked 6 with Schache playing next to him. He looked far more effective when naughts was out there (if anything Naughton was struggling). He was never the sole key forward at the Saints and GWS. He was always a player who worked best as a tandem.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

Bruce is a distraction.

How is it the forward line can’t kick goals? Because there is no coordination between the forwards , or between the midfield and the forwards.

So what has to change? The way the ball is kicked and where it’s kicked. Also, how often it’s kicked.

Then give each player a specific role based on their talent. For example, Dale has never been a play maker. His talent is to find space, receive the ball and kick goals from 35-45 metres. That gives 20 goals in 5 games. But we have played him in a way that might give an occasional goal.

We have only one player who can make a goal out of nothing and that’s Wallis. The rest have to be used better.

Again I agree. Much as Gowers was a distraction last week. This game was lost at the selection table. The decision not to play another tall makes us one dimensional.

[angelopetraglia]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

He kicked 6 with Schache playing next to him. He looked far more effective when naughts was out there (if anything Naughton was struggling). He was never the sole key forward at the Saints and GWS. He was always a player who worked best as a tandem.

He took 43 contested marks in 22 games last year. Elite. He has taken 8 in 10 games this year. Something amiss. The Saints were not exactly handing it to him on a silver platter last year either.

[Eastdog]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

Efficiency Inside 50
Power - 18 shots from 35 inside 50s (51%)
Bulldogs - 19 shots from 39 inside (49%)


Tackles in forward 50
Power - 10
Bulldogs - 15


Marks in 50
Power - 7
Bulldogs - 5

[Danjul]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

Efficiency Inside 50
Power - 18 shots from 35 inside 50s (51%)
Bulldogs - 19 shots from 39 inside (49%)


Tackles in forward 50
Power - 10
Bulldogs - 15


Marks in 50
Power - 7
Bulldogs - 5

39 inside 50s for 5 goals. That’s 1 goal for every 8 entries. That’s terrible.

Now I have done the maths and converted it into a form everyone can understand, it’s over to the coaches to fix the problem.

[Sedat]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

He kicked 6 with Schache playing next to him. He looked far more effective when naughts was out there (if anything Naughton was struggling). He was never the sole key forward at the Saints and GWS. He was always a player who worked best as a tandem.

Bruce was poor in the first 2 games in tandem with Naughton. He has had 9 average to very poor games and 1 excellent game this season - that's unacceptable output on any measure.

[G-Mo77]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

Bruce was poor in the first 2 games in tandem with Naughton. He has had 9 average to very poor games and 1 excellent game this season - that's unacceptable output on any measure.

But Naughton was doing pretty well in those games when Bruce was playing. He's there to take heat off the other guy if there is no Naughton playing there should be Schache out there.

[G-Mo77]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

Bruce is a distraction.

How is it the forward line can’t kick goals? Because there is no coordination between the forwards , or between the midfield and the forwards.

So what has to change? The way the ball is kicked and where it’s kicked. Also, how often it’s kicked.

Then give each player a specific role based on their talent. For example, Dale has never been a play maker. His talent is to find space, receive the ball and kick goals from 35-45 metres. That gives 20 goals in 5 games. But we have played him in a way that might give an occasional goal.

We have only one player who can make a goal out of nothing and that’s Wallis. The rest have to be used better.

I thought McLean was pretty good up there last night. He was drafted as a forward and has done pretty well there before the last season or two, we turned him into an inside mid after that.

[G-Mo77]

Re: WB Game Day V Port Adelaide R10 2020

JJ very emotional after the game

While I feel for players who take on that blame for a loss I wonder if JJ gets back from this. Since 2016 he's had special attention from opposition players and has gone to water. From what I see we have a lot of players when the going is tough they're not mentally strong enough to challenge themselves, challenge their opponent. IMO JJ falls in that category and I wonder if he'll ever be the same.