Cody Head Knock

[comrade]

Re: Cody Head Knock

If he passes all the concussion tests and he's all clear from and a health and wellbeing perspective, can't we just say he was subbed out as a precaution with due to a jaw/facial injury?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Cody Head Knock

If he passes all the concussion tests and he's all clear from and a health and wellbeing perspective, can't we just say he was subbed out as a precaution with due to a jaw/facial injury?

I think so. It’s all up to our medicos and what they say. The club talking to journos and our match report all don’t use the concussion word. At a minimum we want to give him every chance to play.

[DOG GOD]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Why is it always our BEST players that get injured? So unfair.
I’d say Cody will miss and I can’t be Bont being any better than 40%. Is that enough to play…I’m not sure.
God we would miss him, and without him, Port would be $1.12 on Sportsbet.

[1eyedog]

Re: Cody Head Knock

So, how exactly does a "head knock" not be concussion and yet still require the player to be subbed out? I get we're trying to do everything we can to have everyone available but I really hope we're not covering up concussion.

I think we're beyond that in the current climate especially with everything we went through with Picko. Maybe we're being cautious and perhaps he was experiencing some pain rather experiencing concussion related issues. I don't know.

[Bornadog]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Hopefully it isn't concussion.

The Dogs are still investigating whether Weightman suffered a concussion that will force the young forward into the AFL's 12-day protocols, meaning he would definitely miss next week's preliminary final against the Power

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Cody Head Knock

That the club has not seen an obvious case of concussion is a good sign for Cody’s health and for our team sheet this week.

[Bornadog]

Re: Cody Head Knock

That the club has not seen an obvious case of concussion is a good sign for Cody’s health and for our team sheet this week.

Yes, health comes first

[jazzadogs]

Re: Cody Head Knock

That the club has not seen an obvious case of concussion is a good sign for Cody’s health and for our team sheet this week.

It was an interesting substitution. It happened just before half time, so they had bang on 20 minutes until the start of the third - and he was already subbed by then. I thought they typically tested, and then re-tested after 20 minutes.

If there is any doubt and he did have symptoms, then the week off is the right thing to do.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Cody Head Knock

It was an interesting substitution. It happened just before half time, so they had bang on 20 minutes until the start of the third - and he was already subbed by then. I thought they typically tested, and then re-tested after 20 minutes.

If there is any doubt and he did have symptoms, then the week off is the right thing to do.

Yep. Concussion being compounded with another hit is not worth the risk. As it happens, the best outcome for Cody is that he has not suffered a concussion. Which is the best outcome for the side. I find it odd that nearly 24 hours on and there’s still no official word. Perhaps it is a straight up head knock and they’re waiting on a scan on his facial bones. That being the part that seemed to make the impact. Until there is word, I guess we wonder out loud as we head towards a Prelim.

[AshMac]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Just me or was that a free kick to Weightman?

Same thing happened week earlier w Francis…

[EasternWest]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Just me or was that a free kick to Weightman?

Same thing happened week earlier w Francis…

Yes, but I guess it depends on being seen. The Francis one the ball was headed that way so it was reasonable enough that the Ump would have eyes on it.

The Cody one the ball was going towards the goals and I'd imagine eyes were skyward.

[westdog54]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Yes, but I guess it depends on being seen. The Francis one the ball was headed that way so it was reasonable enough that the Ump would have eyes on it.

The Cody one the ball was going towards the goals and I'd imagine eyes were skyward.

Yep. Far enough of the back that it would have gone unseen at the time.

Has the MRO'S report from the game dropped yet?

[FrediKanoute]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Hopefully it isn't concussion.

Its still a head knock though. Concussion or not we shouldn't be taking unecessary chances.

[1eyedog]

Re: Cody Head Knock

Its still a head knock though. Concussion or not we shouldn't be taking unecessary chances.

Even if we are just waiting on an xray and he has no concussion symptoms?

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Cody Head Knock

It's a bad look if we fight this. I think the best (only?) approach would be to argue we were being extremely cautious and sticking to a 12 day protocol at all times might result in teams not being so cautious.