WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

[G-Mo77]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

Our change in intent at the ball and the ball carrier changed the course of the game.

It did, my concern is why does it take a quarter before it kicks in. They should be ready and raring to go, straight out of the blocks.

Is it reactivate coaching? Waiting to absorb their first punch before countering?

[jazzadogs]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

If people are happy with 1 touch for a game then they have lower standards than me.

I thought Cody contributed to a forward line which kicked a big score, and was unlucky not to have at least two shots on goal himself (the West free kick and a courageous mark that wasn't paid). His pressure acts show that he was still in the game.

I'm not convinced that he should have played, but he played his pressure forward role and contributed - a week after kicking 5 and dislocating his elbow.

[Grantysghost]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

I thought Cody contributed to a forward line which kicked a big score, and was unlucky not to have at least two shots on goal himself (the West free kick and a courageous mark that wasn't paid). His pressure acts show that he was still in the game.

I'm not convinced that he should have played, but he played his pressure forward role and contributed - a week after kicking 5 and dislocating his elbow.

McComb had 17 pressure acts.
West 14, Cody 14, JJ 9.

That's the stuff the coaches love; fans can get stuck on what happens with the ball disproportionately.

Edit : Libba just had the lazy 27! What a star.

[Grantysghost]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

Was Bevo's 100th win as coach, first Dog's coach to do so.

[Danjul]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

McComb had 17 pressure acts.
West 14, Cody 14, JJ 9.

That's the stuff the coaches love; fans can get stuck on what happens with the ball disproportionately.

Edit : Libba just had the lazy 27! What a star.

Hate to be the one that shoots Bambi but Weightman should not have been selected. It was the biggest selection blunder I have ever seen.

And to whitewash things by saying he had pressure acts doesn’t cut it. He was poor (he couldn’t move his arm effectively and it looked like he had reduced feeling in his hand) and the selection committee should have known that foreseeable outcome didn’t justify the risks.

And for the record,football is all about the ball. If you want heroes you go to the movies.

[jeemak]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

Hate to be the one that shoots Bambi but Weightman should not have been selected. It was the biggest selection blunder I have ever seen.

And to whitewash things by saying he had pressure acts doesn’t cut it. He was poor (he couldn’t move his arm effectively and it looked like he had reduced feeling in his hand) and the selection committee should have known that foreseeable outcome didn’t justify the risks.

And for the record,football is all about the ball. If you want heroes you go to the movies.

And you've seen and vocalised your fair share of blunders I'd imagine.......

He was a bit stiff not to have had the goal West ended up with, and another shot later in the game. Interestingly, both from overhead marks.

[Bornadog]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

And you've seen and vocalised your fair share of blunders I'd imagine.......

He was a bit stiff not to have had the goal West ended up with, and another shot later in the game. Interestingly, both from overhead marks.

All the posters can try and justify that Weightman had a good game and stats prove nothing. Well, one disposal, and maybe should have been two doesn't cut it and is a vital stat.

Weightman is one of my favourite players, but I was extremely disappointed.

[Grantysghost]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

All the posters can try and justify that Weightman had a good game and stats prove nothing. Well, one disposal, and maybe should have been two doesn't cut it and is a vital stat.

Weightman is one of my favourite players, but I was extremely disappointed.

I don't think he had a "good" game.

But he certainly contributed to the team defence in the forward line and presented all night.

I trust the medicos to know the risks.

He wasn't a 1 possession bad game like a Cory McKernan in the past.

[GVGjr]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

Hate to be the one that shoots Bambi but Weightman should not have been selected. It was the biggest selection blunder I have ever seen.

And to whitewash things by saying he had pressure acts doesn’t cut it. He was poor (he couldn’t move his arm effectively and it looked like he had reduced feeling in his hand) and the selection committee should have known that foreseeable outcome didn’t justify the risks.

And for the record,football is all about the ball. If you want heroes you go to the movies.

I have to agree that the MC got this one wrong. I wonder if that now puts him in doubt for the clash against Brisbane.

[SonofScray]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

All the posters can try and justify that Weightman had a good game and stats prove nothing. Well, one disposal, and maybe should have been two doesn't cut it and is a vital stat.

Weightman is one of my favourite players, but I was extremely disappointed.

Wouldn’t have played him. Appreciated his courage at the contest when he had to go, but was clearly hampered by the arm and didn’t really get in the game. Best I can say is that he took a player, posed a threat in the meta sense, and maybe freed up the avenue for West to funnel the footy through instead.

[jeemak]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

And you've seen and vocalised your fair share of blunders I'd imagine.......

He was a bit stiff not to have had the goal West ended up with, and another shot later in the game. Interestingly, both from overhead marks.

He didn't play very well in terms of productivity with the footy. Had some almost chances and was maniacal at the footy in some instances, while putting on a lot of pressure.

He didn't have a good game and it's possible this was because of his injury, but like some forward pockets do sometimes (and he has in the past when fit), he may have just had a quiet day.

It's likely he'll have surgery at the end of this year on his elbow, and he'll have to play in pain/ discomfort if he wants to play for the rest of the year as it is. He may as well get used to it.

Perhaps after watching the replay it'll be clearer to me as to as to whether/ how much it impacted him.

[chef]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

It was the biggest selection blunder I have ever seen.

Nah, Jose in that Prelim still takes the cake.

[Grantysghost]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

Hate to be the one that shoots Bambi but Weightman should not have been selected. It was the biggest selection blunder I have ever seen.

And to whitewash things by saying he had pressure acts doesn’t cut it. He was poor (he couldn’t move his arm effectively and it looked like he had reduced feeling in his hand) and the selection committee should have known that foreseeable outcome didn’t justify the risks.

And for the record,football is all about the ball. If you want heroes you go to the movies.

Gold Danj!

Should we just sit down when the other team has it?

[Happy Days]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

[G-Mo77]

Re: WB Game Day V Hawthorn R15 2022

I've got no problems with the Weightman selection. They would have needed to put their best small defender on him, letting West out of the cage. It also would have put a few worries about reinjury to bed in his mind. You can call him "pathetic" for his one disposal. I call it a courageous effort.