Charles Sutton Medal

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Lets not confuse Bevo's views on the ruck with how he views Tim. He rates Tim.

Rate your opinion, views and insights highly. However, the Charles Sutton leaderboard doesn't really reflect that after the season that Tim had.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

None of the fab 4 are in our top 6 in the club B&F.

The top 2 in the B&F, won the vote by more than they did in prior years, meaning that they dominated games.

Where was Macrae? English? Naughts? Cody?, B Smith? B Dale?

Pleasing that Ed Richards finished 3rd - talk about break out season!

[Bornadog]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

5 Times winner

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

None of the fab 4 are in our top 6 in the club B&F.

The top 2 in the B&F, won the vote by more than they did in prior years, meaning that they dominated games.

Where was Macrae? English? Naughts? Cody?, B Smith? B Dale?

Pleasing that Ed Richards finished 3rd - talk about break out season!

Think that says a lot about our demise really. The next group coming through are not stepping up.

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

After the Home and Away season. Harris Andrews is winning the Lions B&F. Neale second. Neale can't even win his B&F.

Wins the Brownlow. Doesn't get AA. Doesn't win his own B&F over the Home and Away.

p.s. Dunkley in fourth position

[GVGjr]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Rate your opinion, views and insights highly. However, the Charles Sutton leaderboard doesn't really reflect that after the season that Tim had.

It's not Bevo's award though, it's voted on by a number of people. I just don't think we say Tim's lack of votes is because Bevo doesn't rate ruck man.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Think that says a lot about our demise really. The next group coming through are not stepping up.

To be fair Dale, English, Naughts and JUH finished int he top 10,so I may have jumped the gun

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

To be fair Dale, English, Naughts and JUH finished int he top 10,so I may have jumped the gun

Also, Bont and Libba are generational talents who are still in prime football years. As Pendles showed in the GF, if players have a professional approach to their preparation and lifestyle they can contribute at an elite level well into their 30s.

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

JJ fininished 13th after only playing 11 games, which is the equivilanent of 5th if he played every game. Good comeback on what he had produced in prior years.

[kruder]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Where?s the AA ruck? Don?t the judges rate rucks?

A ruckman won our B&F last year....

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

How does Tim finishing 7th in the B&F impact his decision to stay or leave when he was AA and clearly the best Ruck in the competition this year?

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Jon Ralph

"The Bont 5 best and fairests in ten completed seasons. What a mega star. But Macrae and Smith 14th and 15th sums up what went wrong for the Dogs. In a star driven league Beveridge didn’t maximise his talent"

[jeemak]

Re: Charles Sutton Medal

Jon Ralph

"The Bont 5 best and fairests in ten completed seasons. What a mega star. But Macrae and Smith 14th and 15th sums up what went wrong for the Dogs. In a star driven league Beveridge didn’t maximise his talent"

What vacuous shit.

A star driven league. Absolute pollution.