Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

McComb and Keath out
McLean and Gardner in

Has Crozier got concussion? Would need 12 days out

Edit: just noticed it is a back injury.

[macca]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

Depends which Roarke Smith you're talking about. At his best he's super valuable, at his worst he can go missing too often.

In - McLean, Weightman, Gardner and Duryea
Out - Jones, McComb, Keath and Crozier

Jones or McComb the sub.

The list has some conpetition for spots , a good problem to have

Out : crozier (injured ?), Keath (injury), i hope Lynch gets a few weeks for that dog act
IN : Gardner , Duryea
Sub : Hannan

Persist with Arty as he needs the game and having exposure to tough condition.
I would not be surprised if a few players were sore after tonight and may see 1 or 2 under the ommitted category .

I dont rate McComb as he made a few turn overs today , but the MC must have KPI they see he hits , so i woild keep him in. He does get to the right spots but i just dont see clean execution. But conditions were tough today.

[Missing Dog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

Out: Keath, Crozier, McComb
In: O'Brien, Duryea, Weightman

Reckon Arty Jones gets another week with Weightman coming back. Will be the first time in a long time we will have two designated small forwards.

Couple of smalls on their last chance in my opinion. Ie: Caleb Daniel.

[Missing Dog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

I didn't see the hit on Keath. Will Lynch cop weeks?

[The bulldog tragician]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

Out: Keath, Crozier, McComb
In: O'Brien, Duryea, Weightman

Reckon Arty Jones gets another week with Weightman coming back. Will be the first time in a long time we will have two designated small forwards.

Couple of smalls on their last chance in my opinion. Ie: Caleb Daniel.

I thought he was terrific.

[jeemak]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

I thought he was terrific.

Yeah I reckon Caleb was amazing in the last and pretty good in the first. He needs to build on it a bit to get back to his confident self with ball in hand but today was a good game for him.

[Testekill]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

I didn't see the hit on Keath. Will Lynch cop weeks?

It looked purely accidental to me.

[Bigdog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

If I were in charge I’d do:

Out - Keathe, Cleary, McLean

In - TOB, Crozier, McComb

Sub - Hannan

TOB is performing better in the magoos than Gardiner at the moment. I think he could be okay this year as he might be better at playing a 3rd banana than Gardiner or Keathe as his intercepting is good and kicking is close to elite although he can make poor decisions.

MC a will probably give Duryea a go over Cleary, but I thought Duryea looked a bit slow in the 2s and got caught a few teams. Also think we need some youth to add some more spark to the side.

Mclean a no brainer as he had 45. Needs to have a run in the mid tho.

Hannan is unlucky to be named on the field - did his job yesterday.

[Hotdog60]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

I didn't see the hit on Keath. Will Lynch cop weeks?

I think he will get a week if the AFL is going to protect the head.
Lynch didn't contest the mark and decided to turn his body and bump Keath making it more a hip and should hit to the head causing a player to be subbed with concussion.
In the old days nothing these days he should miss.

[GVGjr]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

If I were in charge I’d do:

Out - Keathe, Cleary, McLean

In - TOB, Crozier, McComb

Sub - Hannan

TOB is performing better in the magoos than Gardiner at the moment. I think he could be okay this year as he might be better at playing a 3rd banana than Gardiner or Keathe as his intercepting is good and kicking is close to elite although he can make poor decisions.

MC a will probably give Duryea a go over Cleary, but I thought Duryea looked a bit slow in the 2s and got caught a few teams. Also think we need some youth to add some more spark to the side.

Mclean a no brainer as he had 45. Needs to have a run in the mid tho.

Hannan is unlucky to be named on the field - did his job yesterday.

Of form it could very well be a line ball decision between TOB and Gardner. I think Bevo will go with Gards though
Agree that McLean needs to come in for McComb. Cleary for Crozier might be one to consider.

[Stevo]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

If I were in charge I’d do:

Out - Keathe, Cleary, McLean

In - TOB, Crozier, McComb

Sub - Hannan

TOB is performing better in the magoos than Gardiner at the moment. I think he could be okay this year as he might be better at playing a 3rd banana than Gardiner or Keathe as his intercepting is good and kicking is close to elite although he can make poor decisions.

MC a will probably give Duryea a go over Cleary, but I thought Duryea looked a bit slow in the 2s and got caught a few teams. Also think we need some youth to add some more spark to the side.

Mclean a no brainer as he had 45. Needs to have a run in the mid tho.

Hannan is unlucky to be named on the field - did his job yesterday.

I dont mind this analysis but Weightman has to be considered doesnt he? It might be wrong to drop King Arthur but Weightman offers so much more.

[SquirrelGrip]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

Out: Keath, Crozier (both inj), Scott (rest), McComb
In: Gardner, Cleary, McLean, Weightman
Sub: Hannan

Scott had work done on his knee last night and may benefit from a week off.

[Mantis]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

Of form it could very well be a line ball decision between TOB and Gardner. I think Bevo will go with Gards though
Agree that McLean needs to come in for McComb. Cleary for Crozier might be one to consider.

It’s an expected move, but Toby is just as ineffective as a full time forward as McComb so unless he’s going to get serious midfield minutes it’s just rinse & repeat.

[Happy Days]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

It’s an expected move, but Toby is just as ineffective as a full time forward as McComb so unless he’s going to get serious midfield minutes it’s just rinse & repeat.

Disagree. The move might not get the most out of Toby but he’s a much more reliable and polished player than McComb is. He won’t miss the simple targets, won’t lose mind blowing ground ball one on ones with 5m of space, and won’t induce a panic attack at the thought of him taking a set shot 15m out dead in front.

[EasternWest]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 5 V Port Adelaide

won’t induce a panic attack at the thought of him taking a set shot 15m out dead in front.

We only have these reactions when it's Bont.