Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

[G-Mo77]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Who do you Sub

I have no idea. Just saying it doesn't make much sense having him as our sub. I wouldn't have him in the team if it were up to me.

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Can't wait for that injection of skill, composure and elite finishing in the last quarter when we desperately need it.

Would you prefer him to start then? lol

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Good call. I think McNeil takes Garcia's role and Garcia play more inside mid.

I'm fine with McNeil getting another run. He had a good pre-season as a small forward (was one of the big improvers) and the cupboard is pretty bare at Footscray.

Last chance saloon but let's see if he can recreate some of what we saw in pre-season where he actually looked like a small forward.

We are top of the ladder and undefeated!

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

I have no idea. Just saying it doesn't make much sense having him as our sub. I wouldn't have him in the team if it were up to me.

Who makes sense as a sub in general though? The sub is used so conservatively Bevo basically brings them on during the last quarter if possible. All things being equal I'm not sure it matters who it is in that scenario they wont make an impact.

[westbulldog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

McNeil is scraping the barrel, can't kick a goal from 30m out dead in front under the roof, dud selection, nafa.

[merantau]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

I think the sub should be a player who we think might eventually make it as a player. It's an opportunity to give someone game time at the highest level.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

In: Lobb, JOD, McNiel
Out: Naughton, Edwards, Scott

Pies have Mihochek and Pendlebury out amongst others.

Think they spelt Rypstra wrong

[azabob]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Good call. I think McNeil takes Garcia's role and Garcia play more inside mid.

I'm fine with McNeil getting another run. He had a good pre-season as a small forward (was one of the big improvers) and the cupboard is pretty bare at Footscray.

Last chance saloon but let's see if he can recreate some of what we saw in pre-season where he actually looked like a small forward.

I tend to agree on McNeil. By all reports he is playing well at Footscray.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

On the AFL website it already has Sanders as the sub?

[jeemak]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

On the AFL website it already has Sanders as the sub?

Maybe an error as he started there last week?

[The Pie Man]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Freija the sub makes sense to me, seems capable in various spots.

I like that we’re bringing in a small forward, just surprised it’s Lachie. Clarke would love a Friday night.

My biggest surprise is Keath - who will he play on? He looked awfully finished at times last week

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

McNeil isn't who I would have picked but I think the type of selection that is extremely overrated in value by fans. I'd have him as sub as 1/ (most importantly) the other 22 are better than him and 2/ he offers speed and I am assuming pressure is why he is there. These suit coming on as a sub.

Decisions we make based on curbing N Daicos, how we rotate/use our talls up forward to ensure they aren't too top heavy, who we play Keath on, what we do with Bont mid/fwd rotation wise etc, these are all heaps more important than whether we select McNeil, Baker or Poulter. Not excusing a bad decision due to lack of importance but I am not thinking it's THAT bad and more so, who I would have picked isn't THAT good.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

McNeil is scraping the barrel, can't kick a goal from 30m out dead in front under the roof, dud selection, nafa.

[The Doctor]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

Despite his patchy form at AFL level, the Dogs have a 65% winning rate when McNeill is in the team. He could be our saviour

[Hotdog60]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 12 vs Collingwood

McNeil will start in the FP and kick 5 goals and get a 4 year extension.