Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

[GVGjr]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Surely Garcia has signed elsewhere already

Apparently has an offer from Port and the Eagles might have reached out to him.

[1eyedog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

I'm not a massive Garcia fan but his non-selection is bordering on ridiculous.

[Testekill]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Garcia must have given his notice; 34 touches, 2 goals and 17 tackles is a monster game even if he was sloppy in the first half of the VFL. Utterly absurd that he couldn't make the team.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Surely Garcia has signed elsewhere already

Yep. Hard to see him playing with us next year.

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

BF rumour has it from the west that Garcia has signed with the Dogs for two. I love a good rumour ha

I would have been tempted to play Keath in this one but yeah our defenders did fairly well last week.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

BF rumour has it from the west that Garcia has signed with the Dogs for two. I love a good rumour ha

That’s crazy……. We give him two years (allegedly) to not give him minutes as a sub or promote him after good form. Why would we blow a list spot like that?

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

That’s crazy……. We give him two years (allegedly) to not give him minutes as a sub or promote him after good form. Why would we blow a list spot like that?

If he has signed then have the ability to play the longer game with him, thats my feel. It was obvious watching him in the VFL that he has been told to work on his defensive game.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Bench might help people decide

[27] Joel Freijah,
[11] Jack Macrae,
[30] Lachlan McNeil,
[25] Caleb Poulter,
[9] Ryley Sanders

Macrae.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

In Treloar and Naugthon
Out Garcia and Gallagher

Please fix Naughton I feel like I have a lisp.

Its like Ibiza!

[BornInDroopSt'54]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

BF rumour has it from the west that Garcia has signed with the Dogs for two. I love a good rumour ha

I would have been tempted to play Keath in this one but yeah our defenders did fairly well last week.

Where is the west?
Surely we are west.

[The Underdog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

I'm not a massive Garcia fan but his non-selection is bordering on ridiculous.

Who does he replace in the selected team?

[whythelongface]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

That’s crazy……. We give him two years (allegedly) to not give him minutes as a sub or promote him after good form. Why would we blow a list spot like that?

How are we blowing a list spot? He is only 23 and if he has signed on for a couple more then hopefully he becomes more consistent and is able to hold onto a senior spot. Until then we have a stacked midfield that doesn’t warrant any change for a fringe player. Sure the argument could be he replaces VDM or McNeil but right now they are role players who are obviously doing a job that perhaps Garcia isn’t as good at doing. I don‘t quite get the angst in his non-selection - it is not like he is one of our top liners not getting selected. If he does leave at the end of the year for more opportunities then so be it - certainly West Coast would be a better fit than Port given their midfield, unless Butters comes across to us.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

How are we blowing a list spot? He is only 23 and if he has signed on for a couple more then hopefully he becomes more consistent and is able to hold onto a senior spot. Until then we have a stacked midfield that doesn’t warrant any change for a fringe player. Sure the argument could be he replaces VDM or McNeil but right now they are role players who are obviously doing a job that perhaps Garcia isn’t as good at doing. I don‘t quite get the angst in his non-selection - it is not like he is one of our top liners not getting selected. If he does leave at the end of the year for more opportunities then so be it - certainly West Coast would be a better fit than Port given their midfield, unless Butters comes across to us.

Tongue in cheek WTF.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Garcia must have given his notice; 34 touches, 2 goals and 17 tackles is a monster game even if he was sloppy in the first half of the VFL. Utterly absurd that he couldn't make the team.

Who would you drop? I agree he has played a stellar game, but who that is in the team that he could replace deserved to be dropped?

[whythelongface]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 19 VS Geelong

Tongue in cheek WTF.

Righto. Not sure how one picks that up. Anyway others are questioning his non-selection thus a rebuttal towards that argument.