Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

[comrade]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

Who subs?

I?d go with Caleb again.

[GVGjr]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

Who subs?

It should be Daniel again but probably Poulter

[josie]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

Should we be concerned Jones is on sub list? Possibly was last week - cannot recall.

[Stevo]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

Should we be concerned Jones is on sub list? Possibly was last week - cannot recall.

From memory he was on the bench last week. You gotta trust the training reports

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

It should be Daniel again but probably Poulter

I think it will be Garcia.

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

I think it will be Garcia.

Let?s hope not. Daniel as sub for me.

I would love to match Garcia up on Very new for the night. See who comes out on top. I recon Garcia would drive him mad even without the ball anywhere near them.

[josie]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

I think it will be Garcia.

I think Garcia is promising and was pretty good in tight situations with his quick thinking and speed, however I think he can be undisciplined eg on Sunday after free awarded to Swans inside our F50 I think he almost cost team 50m penalty trying to be tough (probably should have been) inside our F50 on weekend. There was I think a tackle too where he took it a bit far and it was a free to GWS. I think he has a bit of white line fever and just needs to rein it in a notch. Having said this I hope he is not sub and Caleb or Macrae is. Poulter has been good and really hope he’s in starting line up too.

[Uninformed]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

So as predicted in the Doggy-Bag Takeaway from yesterdays training session there is no change from our line-up against the Swans.

Superbly done!

[The bulldog tragician]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

It is painful to say it but in his brief sub appearance last week Caleb did not inspire. He slowed up play - has definitely lost confidence in his kicking - and then there was the inevitable backline mismatch or two. If he comes into the selected side I’m not sure of his spot, and to be sub again seems a bit weird and even unfair on him.

[Happy Days]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

I’d be really surprised if Poulter is the sub. He’s playing a very clearly defined role.

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

I think Garcia is promising and was pretty good in tight situations with his quick thinking and speed, however I think he can be undisciplined eg on Sunday after free awarded to Swans inside our F50 I think he almost cost team 50m penalty trying to be tough (probably should have been) inside our F50 on weekend. There was I think a tackle too where he took it a bit far and it was a free to GWS. I think he has a bit of white line fever and just needs to rein it in a notch. Having said this I hope he is not sub and Caleb or Macrae is. Poulter has been good and really hope he’s in starting line up too.

Macrae not picked Josie.

[Pleather Sole]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 21 VS Melbourne

It is painful to say it but in his brief sub appearance last week Caleb did not inspire. He slowed up play - has definitely lost confidence in his kicking - and then there was the inevitable backline mismatch or two. If he comes into the selected side I’m not sure of his spot, and to be sub again seems a bit weird and even unfair on him.

Agreed, he's not a great choice as sub these days. Time has caught up with him. I'd like to see him at FF or HF rotating with the small fwds.
I know the line-up can often mean nothing but when I saw Vandermeer listed at centre it made me wonder if he might find his mojo there. McNeil plays well as sub and has a real impact, especially now as he seems to have settled his nerves a notch.