Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Sanders is a better player, but right now Garcia is better at the AFL role either would play

Sanders can bide his time he has plenty of it.
We can not change the team at the moment unless it's for injury.

Garcia is a must for mine.

[Grantysghost]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Anyone for Coffield at the moment needs to build confidence through the VFL.

Coff will be important at the pointy end. I want to pump as many games into him as we can.
Freijah is young, I'm happy to stick with Coffield although he had some poor moments last night.

[comrade]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

No calls for McNeil or VDM to be dropped for probably the first time in?well?ever!

[angelopetraglia]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Abby Holmes was told by the club that the sub was purely a management/tactical one.

Libba on "Roaming Brian" said he rolled his ankle.

[kruder]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

VDM also had a tight hammy was reported on 7 by Cleary.

[whythelongface]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Coff will be important at the pointy end. I want to pump as many games into him as we can.
Freijah is young, I'm happy to stick with Coffield although he had some poor moments last night.

Tend to agree with Coffield. Looks like a solid unit but lacks some composure with the ball in hand. If it is not Coffield then Friejah comes in. Not sure it is the right time for Buss to debut.

[GVGjr]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

VDM also had a tight hammy was reported on 7 by Cleary.

We should be able to confirm that his on Tuesday

[azabob]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

As Doc mentioned we need to start locking down our best 23 players and best two words in footy this time of year when it comes to team selection is NO CHANGE.

Looking ahead;

From Fridays team players vulnerable to form lapses are; Daniel, Garcia, Khamis, Coffield, McNeil, Poulter, Lobb

Possibles are: Sanders, Freijah, Macrae, Gallagher, Keath, Baker, Harmes and JOD. Some reasonable depth if the last two can get on the park. Tony Scott, Gardener and JJ would also be considered but they are too far gone injury wise IMO.

The way I see it is

Daniel is competing with Macrae and Harmes
Sanders is competing with Garcia
Poulter is competing with Gallagher and Baker
Khamis, Coffield, are competing with Freijah, JOD
Lobb is competing with himself and Keath
McNeil is competing with himself

This week I would bring in Freijah for Coffield. I am not sold on Khamis but JOD is the logical replacement but has not strung together more than two games since our disaster in Adelaide.

[Bullies]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Coffield was slow to react at times. Buku got caught ball watching and didn't attack the ball enough but still enough to retain his spot. I think Freijah comes in.

I thought Vandemeer muffed a lot of good opportunities but was in the action a lot more than McNeil. I still think there's a place for Macrae in the side now that we will be playing finals. And Sanders too has to be in the mix along with JOD

Buku is fine if he can play loose man/interceptor on the back line but as you say when he has to play on an opponent he gets caught ball watching. He has no touch or awareness on his opponent. Sides will play through whoever Buku is on.

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

The way I see it is

Daniel is competing with Macrae and Harmes
Sanders is competing with Garcia
Poulter is competing with Gallagher and Baker
Khamis, Coffield, are competing with Freijah, JOD
Lobb is competing with himself and Keath
McNeil is competing with himself

Ok I agree with your views. Well done by the way I would rate them in order as below
Harmes, Macrae the Daniel. We need pace and grunt.
Garcia then Sanders only as Garcia has mongrel In him. This is important in September
Baker, Poulter then gags. Experience is needed in September
JOD, Coffield, Khamis then Freijah. This is the hardest line as it will depend on role and match ups game day
Lobb any day over Keith. Keith is cooked

Anyway what a great position to be in and we hope they stay healthy as it could be anything come September

[jeemak]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

I'm not as down on Coffield as others are. He's versatile in terms of who he can play on and given his time out of the game the past few years has plenty of improvement in him most likely.

On the same thread, I'm not as positive as others are on Garcia. He was better this week but really ****s about with it and this can make him kick it in the air a bit. I do like his intent and he seems to be a bit less prone to ill-discipline than he has been in the past.

[The bulldog tragician]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Ok I agree with your views. Well done by the way I would rate them in order as below
Harmes, Macrae the Daniel. We need pace and grunt.
Garcia then Sanders only as Garcia has mongrel In him. This is important in September
Baker, Poulter then gags. Experience is needed in September
JOD, Coffield, Khamis then Freijah. This is the hardest line as it will depend on role and match ups game day
Lobb any day over Keith. Keith is cooked

Anyway what a great position to be in and we hope they stay healthy as it could be anything come September

I think Poulter has gone past Baker who has only played 39 games and never found consistency. I?ve been impressed with his last few weeks.

[jeemak]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

I think Poulter has gone past Baker who has only played 39 games and never found consistency. I?ve been impressed with his last few weeks.

Poulter is my new Roarke Smith 2021.

That guy who just does his job imperfectly but close enough to perfect who knows how to have an impact or has skills enough to make a difference at the right time.

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

We should never drop King McNeil

[Bornadog]

Re: Always Right Match Committee Round 22 VS Adelaide

Does Harmes comes straight back in?