Brownlow Medal 2024

[G-Mo77]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

What an embarrassing count for the AFL. I guess it's what to expect from our umpires though. Our game is in the worst state it's ever been, it's umpiring is the worst it has ever been and the leaders if this game are the worst they have ever been. This count is a reflection of that.

[Boots]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

His nickname should be boots.

huh?

🤣

[jazzadogs]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

They should swap the Brownlow and Coaches Award. Release the Brownlow votes each weekend, and have a round by round count of the coaches award which will actually see a range of positions recognised. Will still be won by a midfielder...

45 and 38 votes is a joke.

[Mantis]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

First time since I was about 5 that I didn't watch a second of the count.

The lob-sided nature of the vote count saved me from losing my mind... what an embarrassing situation for the AFL.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

First time since I was about 5 that I didn't watch a second of the count.

The lob-sided nature of the vote count saved me from losing my mind... what an embarrassing situation for the AFL.

I watched 1 round but otherwise, exactly the same, It's the first count I've not watched.

The AFL are too far up their own ass to read the room and recognise the Brownlow Medal is now more of a comedy skit than anything else.

[Happy Days]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

I don't know what this means but as it has a whiff of damaging my newfound affection for him I'll pretend it didn't happen.

He?s a big lobster boy guy. Maybe even bigger than Tom McDonald and his unironic all meat diet.

[EasternWest]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

He?s a big lobster boy guy. Maybe even bigger than Tom McDonald and his unironic all meat diet.

Damn. I'm.out.

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

First time since I was about 5 that I didn't watch a second of the count.

The lob-sided nature of the vote count saved me from losing my mind... what an embarrassing situation for the AFL.

Yep. Didn’t watch a second of it. Posted on here during the count and then only actually looked at the results this morning.

Every group chat I’m in has basically panned it. Seems
Pretty universal across the board that folks think it’s a joke.

[chef]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

It's just a fluff night, don't know why anyone bothers to watch it or get upset about it.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

What an embarrassing count for the AFL. I guess it's what to expect from our umpires though. Our game is in the worst state it's ever been, it's umpiring is the worst it has ever been and the leaders if this game are the worst they have ever been. This count is a reflection of that.

I don't know. I think the brownlow night sums up the current state of the AFL very well.

[GVGjr]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

First time since I was about 5 that I didn't watch a second of the count.

The lob-sided nature of the vote count saved me from losing my mind... what an embarrassing situation for the AFL.

I haven't watch a Brownlow medal count in any serious way for a few years now and like you I didn't watch a minute of it last night. Most times it's just a few minutes here and there that I've viewed before I lose interest. I hated they way Gil would call players names who were in contention to try and manufacture more excitement. Then there is the issue with the way some players seem to get more votes than they really should.

[mjp]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

I haven't watch a Brownlow medal count in any serious way for a few years now and like you I didn't watch a minute of it last night.

Same.

I'm not interested in individual awards and I'm REALLY not interested in the umpires interpretation of who the best players are.

I'm obviously pleased for Cripps but that's where it starts and ends for me.

[Sedat]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

Bont polling lower than expected is actually a really good thing - clearly there was less reliance on him to shoot the lights out for us this year, and we got a far more even spread of contributors throughout the season. The "Bont or bust" years of 2021-2023 are thankfully behind us - they are obviously not behind Carlton, who are in a world of hurt until Cripps gets some proper help from the next tier. Ditto Collingwood with Daicos (unfortunately those pricks pinched one last year).

Bont's seasons in 2021 and 2023 were individually far better than 2024 IMO.

[bulldogsthru&thru]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

Same.

I'm not interested in individual awards and I'm REALLY not interested in the umpires interpretation of who the best players are.I'm obviously pleased for Cripps but that's where it starts and ends for me.

It's just weird how the umpires opinions are viewed as the greatest. The whole thing is just weird and has been normalised for so long in the afl space that they don't realise how weird it would appear to outsiders. I kind of liken it to the guns situation in the USA. They don't realise how much they've normalised something so senseless.

[SonofScray]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2024

Bont polling lower than expected is actually a really good thing - clearly there was less reliance on him to shoot the lights out for us this year, and we got a for more even spread of contributors throughout the season. The "Bont or bust" years of 2021-2023 are thankfully behind us - they are obviously not behind Carlton, who are in a world of hurt until Cripps gets some proper help from the next tier. Ditto Collingwood with Daicos (unfortunately those pricks pinched one last year).

Bont's seasons in 2021 and 2023 were individually far better than 2024 IMO.

Absolutely.

Just wild to me how in those seasons, and even last year he's found himself on the wrong side of assessments from the umpires for games he clearly was BOG, or thereabouts.

This year the outcome isn't the concern, but it has exposed the process further.