Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

[bulldogtragic]

Ins:

Nil Known/TBA - for -


Outs:

Smith - for -
Macrae? - for -
Daniel? - for -


Re-Signs:

Garcia - 3 years
Khamis - 2 years
McNeil - 2 years
JJ - 1 year
Clarke?
Keath?


Cuts:

AOD (Retired)
Bedendo
Rypstra (Rookie)

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Out:

Caleb for 25
Smith for 17 & pick upgrade
Macrae for 45


In:

Kennedy for 38
No XOH



Draft Hand: 17, 25, 35 & 48

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Do we know what the pick upgrade with Geelong is?

[Testekill]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

I am glad that Smith is out of our hair, unlike Dunkley I don't think he's the type of player where losing him will bite us in the arse. He's quick and flashy but he's a fundamentally bad kick of the ball and you can't really carry many of them.

[Testekill]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Do we know what the pick upgrade with Geelong is?

From the sound of it we upgraded 45 to 38.

[MrMahatma]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Is there a poll to rate it?

[hujsh]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Do we know what the pick upgrade with Geelong is?

They got 45 (macrae) we got 38
38 for kennedy

They basically just paid the difference between macrae and kennedy

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Is there a poll to rate it?

Use your words…

Or grade it.

[hujsh]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Pretty down on this one. Maybe the draft will change things up

[MrMahatma]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Use your words…

Or grade it.

Shit house.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

As a group:

Smith, CD & Jack > 17, 25 & Kennedy (saving about $1.5M)

[GVGjr]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

I'd give this a rating of B-.

We appeared to play a weak hand quite strongly so well played Sam Power.

[Jeanette54]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

IMHO pretty much our worst trade period ever.

Good luck converting the picks gained by the Macrae and Daniels trades for anyone even close to the players they are. Quite apart from the sadness of losing two heart and soul Bulldogs.

I guess we didn't have much choice with BS, however only time will tell if it's a plus for Geelong. He is your problem now.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Rubbish hand.

C.

Let's see what the draft brings.

[chef]

Re: Rating the 2024 Trade Period (after 7.30 Wednesday)

Went backwards. Need to draft well.