Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

[1eyedog]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

OUT: Cam Mooney from what I've read. Punched someone in the head trying to spoil, except no eyes for the ball, and the ball arrived 5 minutes later

Nothing in it. He tried to but missed.

[1eyedog]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

As I said in the Slaps and Sledges thread he's falling into Sockeye's 'pre-20 games legend, post 20 games dud' rule.

Thought he held Miller well who was second behind Riewoldt for marks on the lead this season.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

I'd say the players under the microscope will be Addison, Everitt and Williams.

Williams beat his direct opponent today, won't get dropped.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

Tim Callan will be needed this week as the Cats have dangerous small forwards.

Depending on who is available I would consider - Hargrave, Higgins, Callan and Tiller as ins and the outs would consist of Murphy (inured) Everitt and Addison.

My guess is that there will be just two changes if Hargrave and Higgins are available.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

Gee Murphy is a cruel blow. He looked really good today before he went down.

I can only see one change

In Shaggy
Out Murphy

Is Callan even available? Tiller should be considered if Shaggy doesn't get up.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

Is Callan even available? Tiller should be considered if Shaggy doesn't get up.

In the bests for Willy (not sure how valuable a guide that is). I think we should play Callan. The Cats have heaps of dangerous small forwards and if Callan is ever going to have a match up, it will be against his old side.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

In: Shaggy, Higgins
Out: Murphy, Harbrow

Harbrow out as he wasn't flash hot today. But maybe I'm just bias towards Everitt as I'm a big fan of his. I thought he did well today and I'd like to see him against the comps best.

[AndrewP6]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

LOL!!!
You might've been handing out a fair amount of gold then today. I think 1 Dee's player collected an ump, and 2 Dogs I think either Cross/Boyd as well as Cooney?

Yep, I'd pay up for all of them if I had the dough...it'd be worth it...oh, to be a millionaire....hell, I'd be happy to be a thousandaire...

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

No mention of dropping Picken. If he plays who will be his match up and is he capable of stopping him? Geelong have a lot of players we need to stop, is it better to attack than defend them?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

In: CAllan - to play his old club, will hopefully provide a bit of spark.
Shaggy
Higgins

Out: Murphy
Addison (knock to his knee)
Everitt

Before yesterday's game I thought we were a chance against the Cats - now I am not so confident

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

No mention of dropping Picken. If he plays who will be his match up and is he capable of stopping him? Geelong have a lot of players we need to stop, is it better to attack than defend them?

Heaps of options. He can pick up Ablett in a tag team effort with Boyd, like he did against Judd. He can also pick up Steve Johnson who is spending more time in the middle.

[BulldogBelle]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

In
Tim Callan
Shaggy
Higgins


Out
Murphy
Addison
Everitt (if we play Morris, Callan, Shaggy, Harbrow and Gilbee back I dont really see a mid match up for him

I still think we need to explore someone who is going to make some better contests at CHF....Lake or Skipper...especially with Murp out....regardless that our strategy is fast movement in the forward line an occasional bomb will still go forward

Hahn is a flanker or pocket......he uses his bulk in a contest, but he raraly gets off the ground or puts his arms in the air

[soupman]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

soupaman, who won the battle today, Williams or Miller?

Miller has been in terrific form.

Don't take it as me bagging Williams, calling for his omission, or saying he's not going to make it. I think he beat Miller well on the weekend. What I'm suggesting is that he doesn't seem to be as much of an attacking player as he has been in the past, even if thats just taking a couple of marks down back or backing himself to kick long. I'll repeat: By no means is he not playing well.

[Mofra]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

In: Shaggy, Higgins
Out: Murphy, Harbrow.

I gave Harbrow votes for his game. Takes the opposition on which is the only way are going to beat Geelong.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 9 Ins and Outs Vs Geelong

I gave Harbrow votes for his game. Takes the opposition on which is the only way are going to beat Geelong.

He gives me sweaty palms when he does though