Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

[chef]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Out Lake, Welsh and Tiller
In Williams, Murphy and Callan

Callan to play on Nahas who's been in good form.

[Missing-Dog]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

If Lake is reported, Williams if still not 100%, Tiller id drop - Id bring in Everitt or Wight.
Murph in for Welsh (reported)
Callan in for Gilbee if needed

[Dazza]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Did they really get reported?

[AndrewP6]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Out: Wallace.

In: ???

Hilarious call.

IMHO - Out : Wallace In: Campbell

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Out
Welsh Suspended
Lake Suspended

In
Williams
Murphy

Chef Harbrow will look after Nahas

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Chef Harbrow will look after Nahas

Could be a terrific matchup. Have followed Nahas pretty closely over the last month, and he is electrifying. Looks to be a good player, and one who can kick a bag.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Could be a terrific matchup. Have followed Nahas pretty closely over the last month, and he is electrifying. Looks to be a good player, and one who can kick a bag.

Nahas has done pretty well and if he was in a better side surrounded by better delivery, one could only feel he'd be even better. Richardson not playing can't help his type of role either, but he's done a pretty good job for them IMO.

Harbrow is the perfect match-up and it'll be interesting to see them head to head. Both very quick and can change direction on one step.

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Chef Harbrow will look after Nahas

I think there is a case to say that Callan might be the better match-up for Nahas and Harbrow on someone else.

[Sedat]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

I think there is a case to say that Callan might be the better match-up for Nahas and Harbrow on someone else.

Hargrave could also be an option for Nahas, if his near 100% blanket job on Milne last year is any indication.

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Hargrave could also be an option for Nahas, if his near 100% blanket job on Milne last year is any indication.

My assumption was that with Lake out I think Morris and Hargrave might be required on a couple of the Richmond taller guys. Riewoldt has caused us problems in the past so we might not have the luxury of pitting a 190cm player like Hargrave against the 176cm Nahas.

[Sedat]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

My assumption was that with Lake out I think Morris and Hargrave might be required on a couple of the Richmond taller guys. Riewoldt has caused us problems in the past so we might not have the luxury of pitting a 190cm player like Hargrave against the 176cm Nahas.

Has he? I don't remember how he played against us in the drawn game last year, but in round 3 this year Williams completely blanketed him - he ended up with only about 7 or 8 possessions and was a complete non-factor.

Of course my Hargrave on nahas suggestion is predicated on Williams being available to come back into the side this week. If not, you're dead right and we'll need Hargy and Morris to 'play tall' this week.

[boydogs]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

My assumption was that with Lake out I think Morris and Hargrave might be required on a couple of the Richmond taller guys. Riewoldt has caused us problems in the past so we might not have the luxury of pitting a 190cm player like Hargrave against the 176cm Nahas.

I don't think Hargrave is the match up for Nahas but we will by no means be stretched for height by Richmond's forwardline. Williams, Morris, Hargrave, Tiller and Everitt are still available.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

My assumption was that with Lake out I think Morris and Hargrave might be required on a couple of the Richmond taller guys. Riewoldt has caused us problems in the past so we might not have the luxury of pitting a 190cm player like Hargrave against the 176cm Nahas.

I would prefer to play an extra tall defender than play Shaggy on a tall opponent. Forget about Shaggy's height, the role that fits him best is playing against small forwards. He has done some great jobs against very dangerous small forwards in the past 12 months, I actually think he is the most underrated player on our list.

Mitch Morton is another potential dangerous match up. He can be a bit slack with his defensive pressure at times and I would put Shaggy on him and try to burn him going the other way. Nahas forward line defensive pressure is as good as it gets.

Richmond don't have many tall forwards anyway do they? I actually think Morris is more suited on a guy like Jack Riewoldt (or Nick, Pav or Fev for that matter) than a clever quick small forward like Nahas. Not sure whether we can find a match up for both Williams and Tiller such is the smaller structure of their forward line.

I would go with:
Morris on Riewoldt
Shaggy on Morton
Harbrow on Nahas
Tiller/Williams on Pattinson/Simmonds

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

Has he? I don't remember how he played against us in the drawn game last year, but in round 3 this year Williams completely blanketed him - he ended up with only about 7 or 8 possessions and was a complete non-factor.

Of course my Hargrave on nahas suggestion is predicated on Williams being available to come back into the side this week. If not, you're dead right and we'll need Hargy and Morris to 'play tall' this week.

Young Jack kicked a few goals against us from memory and he looked alright on Saturday night. I rate him as a decent prospect so perhaps I'm just giving him too much respect.

[Max469]

Re: Ins and Outs Versus Richmond

They worry me, even when they are shit they give us hell, dare i say dont be surprised if we lose.
Its my nightmare.

My sentiments exactly. They will be out to prove something now.

If we are contenders we need to put them away.

Forget about the "Sacked Coach Syndrome" and just get on with it.

Harbrow should play on Nahas.