Ins and outs v Bombers

[Dry Rot]

Are Welsh and Hill injured?

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Are Welsh and Hill injured?

Welsh copped a knock to the head. Not sure about Hill being injured, but tonight was a dismal effort from him, was very poor and hardly sighted with the exception of a good tackle late in the game.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Out: Williams- he really needs to find some form and continuity in the VFL, he looked terribly underdone and lost tonight

In: Everitt if he plays well for Willy this weekend.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Williams got a game tonight on reputation and was a liability.

Tiller or Everitt to come in.

Also Hill apart from a specky every now and then and late goals isn't doing enough. Reid or Stack perhaps.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Williams got a game tonight on reputation and was a liability.

Agreed.

Williams has shown nothing and didn't deserve to play. He was absolutely terrible tonight.

Reid/Everitt in.

[The Coon Dog]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Agreed.

Williams has shown nothing and didn't deserve to play. He was absolutely terrible tonight.

Reid/Everitt in.

He wasn't great, granted, but his opponent was Leigh Brown, how did he do?

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

He wasn't great, granted, but his opponent was Leigh Brown, how did he do?

Two wrongs don't make a right.

He was caught numerous times between ball watching and his man who was miles off him. If form is the criteria to get into the eam Everitt could have done better.

I know tonight was a shocker, i just hope this is him getting into the swing of things and Tiller hasn't surpassed him, if he is to be the great white hope.

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

He wasn't great, granted, but his opponent was Leigh Brown, how did he do?

Which is the whole point.

It's Leigh Brown, you could of played anybody on him and it wouldn't of made a difference.

We would of done far better with somebody else in the side. A player who was in actual form - Addison/Callan.

Williams' efforts were shocking. He was lucky Cloke missed his easy shot on goal and Swan somehow kicked his out on the full.

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Anyone who saw Williams last week knew he wasn't quite ready but he is certainly one player who doesn't necessarily get promoted to the seniors on form.
If there is a good match up for him for next week we probably should stick with him.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Anyone who saw Williams last week knew he wasn't quite ready but he is certainly one player who doesn't necessarily get promoted to the seniors on form.
If there is a good match up for him for next week we probably should stick with him.

Llyod or Lucas who are both back to some decent form?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

I don't think they will drop Williams now based on the fact that he got through this game. He should be better next week.

Let's smash the bombers!

[LostDoggy]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Williams won't be dropped, and he shouldn't either. He needs games under his belt, and he can't get them playing at Williamstown. He is very vital for our structure, and if he isn't there in finals we will struggle.

[GVGjr]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Llyod or Lucas who are both back to some decent form?

You would have to think Lake on Lloyd is a certainty and Williams against Lucas a possibility.

[Hot_Doggies]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

Once again William's punching with the wrong arm. The play where he crunched Lockyer,he should of punched that with the left and found the line. Let the ball get over the back and resulted in a goal.

Has been a problem at least half a dozen times this year.

[bulldogtragic]

Re: Ins and outs v Bombers

You would have to think Lake on Lloyd is a certainty and Williams against Lucas a possibility.

I hope i eat my words, but i dont like players of such little vintage getting gamnes on reputation. Grant is not for instance. The ability to consistently do your job in the VFL should be the criteria. Everitt has done his job week in and week out and looks no closer to even getting to cut the oranges.