WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

[BulldogBelle]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3. Cooney
2. Griffen
1. Ward

[BulldogBelle]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3 Boydy
2 Eagle
1 Ward

[LostDoggy]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

Eagleton

Cooney

Harbrow

Apologies to lot's and lot's of doggies, Griff, Gia and special kudo's to Ward.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

If peoples views weren't given, questioned and discussed this forum would cease to exist.

This is true, so I guess the point I was trying to make was:

I fail to see why we need to suggest a posters view of the game is less superior to our own

[dadsgirl16]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3.Cooney
2.Griffen
1.Ward

[Mantis]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

This is true, so I guess the point I was trying to make was:

I fail to see why we need to suggest a posters view of the game is less superior to our own

I was just interested in the reasoning for why he gave votes to Morris? Personally I wouldn't have had Dale in our best 15 players, but that's just my view.

I think we have the right to question other people's views (I'm happy for people to question mine) and in this case these questions were answered.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

I was just interested in the reasoning for why he gave votes to Morris? Personally I wouldn't have had Dale in our best 15 players, but that's just my view.

I think we have the right to question other people's views (I'm happy for people to question mine) and in this case these questions were answered.

I agree

I think you questioned Furtanken's view in a light hearted manner

I didn't think Westdogs response was quite as light hearted

I would have thought given the importance of shutting down Bradshaw that you would have rated Dales game more highly, but I can live with a different perspective

Should I presume that you ranked Morris at #16, one spot ahead of Eagle at #17

[LostDoggy]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3. Boyd
2. Griff
1. Harbrow

Apologies to Ward, Cooney, and Eagle!

[LostDoggy]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

I was just interested in the reasoning for why he gave votes to Morris? Personally I wouldn't have had Dale in our best 15 players, but that's just my view.

I think we have the right to question other people's views (I'm happy for people to question mine) and in this case these questions were answered.

My call is usually just as I see the game.
I don't go back and check stats to make my decision.
As for why I chose Morris, I thought he did exceptionally well in keeping Bradshaw to 3.
Bradshaw was looking like he could have kicked a lot more, and set up a lot more.

You calls it as you sees it?

You musn't have seen when Jarrod Harbrow was busy keeping his opponent stone cold through 4 quarters.

Or when Harbrow put himself in J. Brown's path to make a spoil.

Or when he ran out of defence and bounced his way towards setting up a goal to Higgins.

Come to think of it, I'm starting to get curious as to what game you were watching.

I saw that.
I also saw him hesitate initially and pull out of the exact same situation 5 minutes prior.

Anyhow, as already pointed out, this is irrelevant.
My one vote for Morris won't count anyhow.

For the record I just checked the game ratings from the AFL WEBSITE:

Jarrod Harbrow – 7
Another excellent performance across half-back in the youngster's breakout season. Played on Rhan Hooper and shut him out, but also provided plenty of run from behind.

Dale Morris – 7
Matched up on Daniel Bradshaw and got led to the ball a couple of times early before tightening up on the dangerous Lion. Had three goals kicked on him, but probably shaded his opponent.

Guess I'm not alone.
Who's harder to shut out of the game?
Bradshaw or Hooper?

[Missing Dog]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

Cooney -enough said
Griff-best game all year
Ward- between about sixplayers but this kid is the ducks nuts

[LostDoggy]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3 Cooney
2 Dare I say Fumbleton
1 Gia as predicted

Apol Boyd Grif Cross Ward

[LostDoggy]

Re: WOOF Player Awards – SF2 Western Bulldogs vs Brisbane

3 Ward
2 Gilbee
1 Cooney