Hutchy and Dylan

[Doc26]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

DFA's disposal choice under pressure and turnovers have been costly at times but think he's worth persevering with for another season. It's not like we have a lot of depth when injuries hit and his hardness at the ball is an asset. I'd be playing hardball with Sydney on Dylan.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

Dylan is a fringe player that was a lot better in 2008 than this year. I think it is a reasonable trade straight swap for Hall and an exchange of draft picks our third for their fourth.

[Doc26]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

Dylan is a fringe player that was a lot better in 2008 than this year. I think it is a reasonable trade straight swap for Hall and an exchange of draft picks our third for their fourth.

That he is but just don't feel it's required in this case. Within reason loyalty should go both ways. We're bagging Brian and Andrejs and then talking of throwing out a young kid who has shown nothing but passion and dedication for the RW&B. If he wants to go then it's another story.

[Topdog]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

That he is but just don't feel it's required in this case. Within reason loyalty should go both ways. We're bagging Brian and Andrejs and then talking of throwing out a young kid who has shown nothing but passion and dedication for the RW&B. If he wants to go then it's another story.

We might not be throwing him out though. There is every chance he would like to go back to NSW.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

We will not be trading any player

Third round pick and that's that and Sydney know that.

[soupman]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

We will not be trading any player

Third round pick and that's that and Sydney know that.

I have full confidence in Eade and company not getting done over with this trade. Every single trade under Eade has been very fair, and I can't see him all of a sudden giving away a draft pick and one of his favourite players for a two year nutcase.

[MrMahatma]

Re: Hutchy and Dylan

Trading a fringe player (DFA) and a pick likely to be nothing more than a fringe player (4th round) for a guy who'll slot straight into our 22 for the next 2 years and give us a chance at a flag?


Do it.