Round 12- Selection changes

[lemmon]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Well Grant is back in the team

[The Pie Man]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Well Grant is back in the team

Where'd you hear/see that? Can't find that news anywhere

Great if so

[lemmon]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Where'd you hear/see that? Can't find that news anywhere

Great if so

SEN just mentioned the high contact was downgraded to mid level and with an early plea he is under the 100 points

[The Pie Man]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

^^^

With that in mind...

In: Callan, Everitt, Murphy, Wood.
Out: Higgins, Hahn, Stack, Addison.

It's the fourth in I'm stuck on - Wood or Reid...or both if you drop Eagle

Those 4 are the easiest outs to pick in a while - though having said that, I get the feeling Hahn will survive.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Great news with Grant, I was even happy with one week.

Bobby and Shaggy will be interesting, would have loved the break to come 2 weeks earlier. I would like us to be cautious with Bobby. Getting his body right is massive for us later in the season. There is a massive temptation to bring them both in as we are struggling to fill out the 22.

I think Callan needs to be ahead of Addison. As much of a negative selection as it looks, Dylan just seems a poor man's version of Callan (that makes for a very poor man). Callan is stronger, more composed and can actually find the ball.

[choconmientay]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Where'd you hear/see that? Can't find that news anywhere

Great if so

Just saw this reported in the news on TV as well. Really happy for Grant. Well done to the club to contested the ban.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

^^^

With that in mind...

In: Callan, Everitt, Murphy, Wood.
Out: Higgins, Hahn, Stack, Addison.

It's the fourth in I'm stuck on - Wood or Reid...or both if you drop Eagle

Those 4 are the easiest outs to pick in a while - though having said that, I get the feeling Hahn will survive.

Of course he will.

[Hotdog60]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Eade said that Wood could become a big possibility this week, I think he'll replace Addison.

[Mantis]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

In: Callan, Everitt, Hargrave, Reid, Wood.
Out: Higgins, Grant, Hahn, Stack, Addison.


I really wanted to drop Eagleton as well but there just wasn't anyone else to bring in and Eagleton may contribute something, the other three were giving nothing at all.

With Grant now safe do you drop Eagleton?

I guess having Murphy also a possible inclusion gives us another option.

Having just watched the game again I think you have those out's + Eagleton correct.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

With Grant now safe do you drop Eagleton?

I guess having Murphy also a possible inclusion gives us another option.

Having just watched the game again I think you have those out's + Eagleton correct.

Offset by Hargrave probably not coming up.

If Murphy plays send him straight to the HBF.


Grant for Eagleton might make us a bit top heavy up forward but it does give us a bit of flexibility if Lake has to take a turn on Brown. Josh Hill will have to take his turn further up the ground.

[FrediKanoute]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Great news with Grant, I was even happy with one week.

Bobby and Shaggy will be interesting, would have loved the break to come 2 weeks earlier. I would like us to be cautious with Bobby. Getting his body right is massive for us later in the season. There is a massive temptation to bring them both in as we are struggling to fill out the 22.

I think Callan needs to be ahead of Addison. As much of a negative selection as it looks, Dylan just seems a poor man's version of Callan (that makes for a very poor man). Callan is stronger, more composed and can actually find the ball.

What Callan offers is the dour, nuggety back pocket type player. Yep he's not going to create, but his man sure as heck isn't going to get too many easy balls.

[Bulldog Revolution]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

In: Callan, Everitt, Wood
Out: Higgins, Hahn, Stack

I suspect neither Murphy or Hargrave will come up, and I'm not convinced Reid is fit enough yet

[GVGjr]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

In: Murphy (Everitt)
Out: Higgins

I'd like to see more changes but there isn't too much point yet, shuffling deckchairs on the Titanic really.

Players we need to see in by the end of the season if we're to have any chance: Johnson, Murphy, Akermanis, Ward, Hargrave

Players out of the team if we are to have any chance: Hahn, Eagleton, Stack, Addison, Moles

The game has gone past Mitch and Eagle and Stack, Addison and Moles aren't at the level required, they might get to to that level but not yet.

A bunch of other guys need to improve a hell of a lot too. Rather than an incremental improvement on last year a number of players are worse in a number of areas, skills and decision making mainly.

[Mantis]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Grant for Eagleton might make us a bit top heavy up forward but it does give us a bit of flexibility if Lake has to take a turn on Brown. Josh Hill will have to take his turn further up the ground.

Grant plays like a small.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Round 12- Selection changes

Grant plays like a small.

He doesn't really.

I agree he's probably quicker than most but he doesn't run as hard and he's not as skilful by foot as a midfielder. I haven't checked any stats but I would suggest that marks still account for about 50% of his possesions.