Mid Season Review

[Go_Dogs]

Re: Mid Season Review

Cheers guys.

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Mid Season Review

My perception of form is totally screwed depending on which moment I lay awake in bed thinking of.
It also depends if I am at the ground or watching it on TV.
Maybe the best way to judge form is by who stuffs up the least.

That is absolutely the worst way to decide.

The person that stuffs up the least isn't taking enough risks and that's a certain way to fail.

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Mid Season Review

Ah yes! good point! what was I thinking!

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Mid Season Review

So on that basis Will Minson is the best guy on our team ! haha

[Sockeye Salmon]

Re: Mid Season Review

So on that basis Will Minson is the best guy on our team ! haha

Just make two columns, one for good stuff, one for bad stuff.



(When you format you might want to make Will's 'bad' column just a touch wider).

[Desipura]

Re: Mid Season Review

That is absolutely the worst way to decide.

The person that stuffs up the least isn't taking enough risks and that's a certain way to fail.

Or is handballing/kicking to a teammate who is under pressure and a fair chance to stuff up. The Farren Ray rule I like to call it.

[hujsh]

Re: Mid Season Review

Well done Griff #16. Great attempts to rate the players and mostly spot on IMO (though I agree Higgins may be a bit high)

[Doc26]

Re: Mid Season Review

Good work Griff.
My points of difference sit only around the margins.
I see Gia's half year performance with a higher std. dev. (with a lower min.) to your other worthy 8+ elite class of Hudson, Cooney, Griff, Lake, and Gilbee and as such would err on moving him down to your '7' class. Would also have Crossy in a similar grouping as he did struggle earlier on following his seriously interrupted pre season. Would be comfortable with Harbrow in your '8' elite class above and the injury afflicted Higgins is on the high side at 6.5.