Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

[Guest]

Okay, its Finals time!

Lets smash the Pies.

Another interesting week at the selection table.

Here are my selections:

In: Higgins, Minson
Out: Addison, Roughead

Hopefully Griffen comes up, otherwise I think Hooper will find himself in with a chance. Wood, if fit.

Everitt, Jones and Hahn remain the other vulnerable players.

[boydogs]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Won't Easton Wood be ready? What's the reasoning behind the ruck change?

[becmatty]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Won't Easton Wood be ready? What's the reasoning behind the ruck change?

Roughead's shoulder kept popping out tonight. We cannot afford that next week. Minson and Roughy are pretty much on level terms, but with Minno performing well, it would be foolish to risk Roughead.

Agree, if Wood is fit, he will be a strong chance.

[comrade]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

IN: Wood, Minson, Higgins
OUT: Addison, Roughy, Hahn

[boydogs]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Roughead's shoulder kept popping out tonight. We cannot afford that next week. Minson and Roughy are pretty much on level terms, but with Minno performing well, it would be foolish to risk Roughead.

Agree, if Wood is fit, he will be a strong chance.

Collingwood are the side we first used the part-time ruck experiment against, and successfully. We may need the extra run against their extended midfield rotation, if Roughead is sore then perhaps Wood can come in for him and Everitt can do some ruckwork

[comrade]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Collingwood are the side we first used the part-time ruck experiment against, and successfully. We may need the extra run against their extended midfield rotation, if Roughead is sore then perhaps Wood can come in for him and Everitt can do some ruckwork

After last week's debacle, I'm not sure the MC would be prepared to pull the trigger on a part time ruck set up again.

[lemmon]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

In- Wood, Minson, Higgins
Out- Roughy, Jones, Hahn

[becmatty]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

In- Wood, Minson, Higgins
Out- Roughy, Jones, Hahn

I thought Hahn was okay tonight. His lack of pace is noticable and that is his biggest vice, but without Morris, I think he is important as an extra option in defense. Adds experience in pressure final also.

[comrade]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

I thought Hahn was okay tonight. His lack of pace is noticable and that is his biggest vice, but without Morris, I think he is important as an extra option in defense.

If we're going to face Collingwood with a depleted squad, I'd much rather a guy like Addison, Wood or Everitt playing defence than seeing Hahn waddle around.

Remember Mitch being ragdolled by Leigh Brown?

[lemmon]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

I thought Hahn was okay tonight. His lack of pace is noticable and that is his biggest vice, but without Morris, I think he is important as an extra option in defense. Adds experience in pressure final also.

That was the key factor for mine, came down to Hahn V Addo and Addisons pace and hopefully ability to play as a defensive forward and apply pressure got him over the line.

[boydogs]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

After last week's debacle, I'm not sure the MC would be prepared to pull the trigger on a part time ruck set up again.

Everitt wasn't playing last week though. Forgetting the MC for a moment, would you do it?

[comrade]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Everitt wasn't playing last week though. Forgetting the MC for a moment, would you do it?

Yeah, I probably would if Wood is 100%.

[ReLoad]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

Everitt really let himself down tonight, he had the best opportunity all year, with the team, the opponent, the role he was going to play, etc. but failed.

His confidence is clearly shot, the kid just doesnt believe in himself, he has to be out of the team, there is no upside to his game right now.

So
Out: Everitt, Addison, Roughhead(inj)
In: Wood, Higgins, Minson.

[Sedat]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

If we're going to face Collingwood with a depleted squad, I'd much rather a guy like Addison, Wood or Everitt playing defence than seeing Hahn waddle around.

Remember Mitch being ragdolled by Leigh Brown?

Addison did a good defensive forward job on Stanton in the first half, who barely had a touch. I'd like to see him take Harry O or Shaw next week in a similar role.

[ReLoad]

Re: Qualifying Final - WOOF Selection Table

I hate to be the prophet of doom, anyone noticing the lack of penetration on Gilbee's kicking over the last 4 weeks? yikes! - Injured? unfit? whats the scoop?