Round #7 Match Committee

[GVGjr]

If you were on the Match Committee who would the likely ins and outs for the round 7 home game at Manuka Oval against the very honest Sydney Swans?

This is another critical game for us.

[GVGjr]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

So who gets a rest?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Roughead, Hill & Grant.

I know it seems as though i am signalling the younger guys out, but i think they need a spell at Williamstown.

[GVGjr]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Roughead, Hill & Grant.

I know it seems as though i am signalling the younger guys out, but i think they need a spell at Williamstown.

Who are you bringing into the side? Hudson and who else?

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Roughead and Hill definitely out for mine.

and Hudson and Stack in (unless he's had a shocker today for Willy)


If Higgins is somehow available, then I'd let Wallis go back down to Willy. I just don't think we can have two kids in Wallis and Libba in our 22 at this point in time.

[The Pie Man]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Roughead looks an obvious call for Hudson, Gia would be a likely in though not sure who for...Moles or Addison I'm guessing.

Libba was ok, but does he need a rest?

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Who are you bringing into the side? Hudson and who else?

Hudson, Higgins & Gia/Stack.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Roughead looks an obvious call for Hudson, Gia would be a likely in though not sure who for...Moles or Addison I'm guessing.

Libba was ok, but does he need a rest?

D'oh I completely forgot about Gia. If available he's a definite.
So I'd refine my ins and outs to be

Out: Roughy, Hill and and Addison
In: Hudson, Stack and Gia.

**If Higgins is somehow available then Wallis goes out.

[choconmientay]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Libba needs a rest. And we are playing Sydney, I would think Libba will struggle against all the big bodies.
Out: Roughy, Libba and Addison
In: Hudson, Higgins, Gia/Moles

Grant should be dropped as well but not sure if we can afford to drop him at the moment?!

[Missing-Dog]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Out
Roughead, Grant, Hill, Wallis

In

Hudson, Gia, Higgins, ..Skinner!!

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Out
Roughead, Grant, Hill, Wallis

In

Hudson, Gia, Higgins, ..Skinner!!

I'm not sure that on the back of one good performance amongst 2 ordinary ones Skinner should be promoted. Let's see him do it more consistently.

[Mantis]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Hudson & Minson in the same team isn't going to work... Will showed today, admitedly against poor opposition, that he is a ruckman.

If Hudson plays Wilbur will only ruck for 25% of the game (which isn't enough) and isn't suited to the role Roughy is currently playing.

[Missing-Dog]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Hudson & Minson in the same team isn't going to work... Will showed today, admitedly against poor opposition, that he is a ruckman.

If Hudson plays Wilbur will only ruck for 25% of the game (which isn't enough) and isn't suited to the role Roughy is currently playing.

I think he could do as good a job or better as Roughy up forward. Roughy didnt give us much today!

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

Hudson & Minson in the same team isn't going to work... Will showed today, admitedly against poor opposition, that he is a ruckman.

If Hudson plays Wilbur will only ruck for 25% of the game (which isn't enough) and isn't suited to the role Roughy is currently playing.

Well then the coaching panel have a dilemma, because at the moment I'm not convinced that Roughy can play the role that he is playing at the moment. I think that Minson deserves another shot at being able to play the resting forward ruck role, until such time (and it may well be some time this season) that Roughy is able to bounce Hudson from the team.
Then Minson can move to first ruck and Roughy resting forward.

I think Will looks to be alot more mobile than he was 12 months ago, and could well make a better fist of things up forward this time around.

[Mantis]

Re: Round #7 Match Committee

I think he could do as good a job or better as Roughy up forward. Roughy didnt give us much today!

Or:

I think Minson could do a better job than Hudson as our no.1 ruck. Hudson hasn't given us much this year.