Round #13 Match Committee

[GVGjr]

If you were on the Match Committee who would the likely ins and outs for the round 13 home game against the Crows side next Friday night at the Docklands?

[GVGjr]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Schofield in for Mulligan is my initial thought.

I wonder if Cooney and Hargrave will be available.

[Bornadog]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Schofield in for Mulligan is my initial thought.

I wonder if Cooney and Hargrave will be available.

Before the game, heard Rocket say that Lake may be a chance next week, who knows. Hall will also be available.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Schofield in for Mulligan is my initial thought.

I wonder if Cooney and Hargrave will be available.

I guess though the ball is in Schofield's court this weekend, providing he doesn't have a shocker you would think he is a good chance.
Coud Roughy be a chance too? Whilst Hudson played well tonight, Melbourne are going with Martin in the ruck who is quite mobile, something Will and Hudson are not.

[Mofra]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

I guess though the ball is in Schofield's court this weekend, providing he doesn't have a shocker you would think he is a good chance.
Coud Roughy be a chance too? Whilst Hudson played well tonight, Melbourne are going with Martin in the ruck who is quite mobile, something Will and Hudson are not.

We should never play Hudson & Minson in the same side again.
Given our season is shot, Hudson would be on thin ice if his form drops again.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Hard to say at this stage. Cooney, Hargrave, Lake, Hall all will be under consideration. Doubt I'd pick any of them though considering we're 3 - 8.

Mulligan is an obvious out.

One of Hudson or Minson. I'd prefer Huddo and thank him for his services.

I didn't think much of Djerrkura's game either.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Barlow out please. Bit of a headless chook performance and gave us nothing really.
Vezpremi would have been a better option.

[Jasper]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Out - Hudson not offering an aerial contest
Out - Djerkurra - I've seen enough - is he seriously going to be at our club for another two years?
Out - Barlowe - ordinary decision making and disposal

In - Hall
In - Cooney
In - Lake

....and back in the land of harsh reality...

It depends on fitness and form. Hopefully Grant and Hill don't play for a little while though. Hopefully Hargrave is given a good spell - his disposal is really ordinary under pressure. Realistically I think we need to pick good decision makers and kicks and if above players aren't fit. Gilbee must be considered.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

I wouldnt play Lake or Cooney til they are 100%. What's the point in risking them now? Hall is finished better we move on asap there.
Hargrave is easily in our best 22.
Gilbee can't get a kick at williamstown and won't get one in afl.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Dolly stays in!
Maybe just Mulli for another young guy. I would give dj another week at least.

[G-Mo77]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

I wouldnt play Lake or Cooney til they are 100%. What's the point in risking them now? Hall is finished better we move on asap there.

I do agree there but I'd give him 1 more game to get him to 300.

[Scorlibo]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

I do agree there but I'd give him 1 more game to get him to 300.

He's another 21 games away from 300..

[Ghost Dog]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Barlow out please. Bit of a headless chook performance and gave us nothing really.
Vezpremi would have been a better option.

rubbish. He was a bit lost at times but he was in hard and did some good things
Give a guy a few games to find his feet will you?

[Dancin' Douggy]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

Out - Hudson not offering an aerial contest
Out - Djerkurra - I've seen enough - is he seriously going to be at our club for another two years?
Out - Barlowe - ordinary decision making and disposal

In - Hall
In - Cooney
In - Lake

....and back in the land of harsh reality...

It depends on fitness and form. Hopefully Grant and Hill don't play for a little while though. Hopefully Hargrave is given a good spell - his disposal is really ordinary under pressure. Realistically I think we need to pick good decision makers and kicks and if above players aren't fit. Gilbee must be considered.

If we had any spare good decision makers and kicks I'd love to play them.
Can't think of any.............

Also, send Cooney straight to the surgeon and get him right for next year....

[azabob]

Re: Round #13 Match Committee

I don't want to see any player play 1 game and then get dropped.

Give them a chance.

Totally agree with this. Young players need to be told ok you have at least 3 weeks to prove your worth to the team.

This goes for players like DJ and Barlow also.