Round #23 Match Committee

[GVGjr]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

So, what's the deal with Minson? Is he cooked as a Bulldogs player, or do you think he'll get a go next year, now that current wearer of The People's Beard is retiring? Does Minson need to grow a cool beard to get promoted?

It's a good question. He's been limited because of his inability to play well enough up forward and I'm not sure this won't be an issue for him again next season. He should be penciled in as the number one ruckman but it may not pan out that way.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

He played well last week so why not give him another go?

Hill is not our future I would rather play a kid that will have a go

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

So Hill in again what joy

His tackling with Willi last week was fierce. He seemed like a different footballer....playing as if he wanted physical contact. If he takes that intensity into the seniors and doesn't let little things get him down, he will be a great addition to our side. I wonder if it's all in the head with Josh....hopefully we can discover the trick to getting the best out of him, and getting his confidence up....because on last week's effort, there's certainly a footballer there.

[LongWait]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

Hill is not our future I would rather play a kid that will have a go

We do get the point Hughy - you don't rate Hill.

[GVGjr]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

Hill is not our future I would rather play a kid that will have a go

He was certainly a spirited competitor last week.

[chef]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

Hill is not our future I would rather play a kid that will have a go

Could have said the same thing about Gilbee under Rohde.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

His tackling with Willi last week was fierce. He seemed like a different footballer....playing as if he wanted physical contact. If he takes that intensity into the seniors and doesn't let little things get him down, he will be a great addition to our side. I wonder if it's all in the head with Josh....hopefully we can discover the trick to getting the best out of him, and getting his confidence up....because on last week's effort, there's certainly a footballer there.

Hope you are right ... but leopards and spots come to mind

[chef]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

He was certainly a spirited competitor last week.

Yep, deserves his chance.

[Greystache]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

Hill is not our future I would rather play a kid that will have a go

I would have picked him this week too, he played well last week and deserves his chance.

I'd rather play Hill who has talent, rather than a player like Reid who has a red hot crack but isn't an AFL footballer.

[Maddog37]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

I think there is more upside in giving Hill a chance than letting him rot at Willy. The unfortunate byproduct is Howard goes out.

Hill can play, we all know that and last week he was very switched on but he will never be a rugged player.

[Bornadog]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

I would have picked him this week too, he played well last week and deserves his chance.

I'd rather play Hill who has talent, rather than a player like Reid who has a red hot crack but isn't an AFL footballer.

Agree - Reid is just not going to cut it I am afraid.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

are you for f@#$ing real "hill deserves a chance" i think he has had his chance in the last few years.
It doesn't matter if he kicks 10 goals and 40 posessions this saturday he is not consistant.
Sorry he had his chance and didn't take it, it makes me sick to see stack,reid,addison emergencies and hill in.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

I would have picked him this week too, he played well last week and deserves his chance.

I'd rather play Hill who has talent, rather than a player like Reid who has a red hot crack but isn't an AFL footballer.

how do you know he is not an afl footballer he has not had chance, unlike hill he has had plenty of chances and proven he is not an afl footballer

[Greystache]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

how do you know he is not an afl footballer he has not had chance, unlike hill he has had plenty of chances and proven he is not an afl footballer

I've watched him play... A lot. He's about 15cm too short to play AFL, he moves and kicks like a ruckman but is the height of a midfielder.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Round #23 Match Committee

I've watched him play... A lot. He's about 15cm too short to play AFL, he moves and kicks like a ruckman but is the height of a midfielder.

Libba had the same problem.