Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

[Missing Dog]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Ins Wallis, Sherman, Vespa, Talia
Outs Roughead, Lake, Smith, Wood

I can't see the 3 ruckman strategy working, not with Roughead and Minson in the same side at least. We need more run and spread.
It's time Vespa got just as good of a run as Wood. Wood has been awful all year and needs a spell. I'd also like to see Wallis get an extended run at it also.
Smith - Too many clangers. He's had 11 out of 26 possessions in the last 2 games.

[Raw Toast]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

I'd drop Wood and groom him for a midfield (run-with) or defensive forward role. I'm struggling to see him developing the awareness needed for his current role.

I also think that Lake will likely miss a week or two after the MRP has a look at that incident.

I'd bring in Vezpremi for Wood and Austin (promoted from rookie list) for Lake.

I'd also consider resting one of the young mids depending on how they pull up, and bringing in Wallis.

It's also tempting to think about how to bring Sherman in, maybe for Roughead.

[Mantis]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Libba was terrible too. I think Cordy at least presented all night which gives him some credits - must have been tempting to drop the head when the delivery into the F50 is that bad.

Yeah Libba was poor, Cordy presented well, but he has to catch a few, especially playing on another kid and with his height & reach advantage.

Did Gia even get to double figures in possessions?

His kick after the siren got him to 9.

He just looked so slow out there.

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

As many have said were do ou start, it has to be one of the worst days at the office that we have Hamas a club,

The backs I thought had been Ok apart from Wood but I think we need to persist with him given that Morris is not yet availible.

The forwards need to get better delivery, but need to look the ball in and be accountable or a man when they have he ball, Gia, Higgins & Grant all had bad games, while Jone and Cordy need better delivery. For me we need to have only 2 of Grant, Cordy and Jones,

The Mids had a shocker, Griff, Boyd, Smith, Libba and Cooney were all down but you can't flick the lot of them.

For me next week I would remove Grant and Higgins as they are front runners and apply no pressure or presence on the field. Lake I'm sure will get weeks also. Ins for these three would be Wallis, Sherman & Veszpremi

[The Bulldogs Bite]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Veszpremi needs to play, be it up forward or down back.

Sherman for some more run.

Wallis to replace Smith.

I'd probably drop Minson before Roughead.

[Hotdog60]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

So you want to bring in a 4th ruckman/forward?

Not another ruck, a dedicated forward. We need someone to take some pressure off Jones, it maybe a bit old fashion but but I feel we need to settle a player there. I suppose there is no quick fix with the players we have.

[GVGjr]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Not another ruck, a dedicated forward. We need someone to take some pressure off Jones, it maybe a bit old fashion but but I feel we need to settle a player there. I suppose there is no quick fix with the players we have.

So where does, Cordy, Hill, Jones, Grant and Roughead play?

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Wow, so woeful.

Disagree with the 3 ruckman strategy more than ever but there are also another million things wrong with us so won't harp on about that.

IN/ Sherman, Wallis, Austin
OUT/ Roughead, Smith, Lake

[Bumper Bulldogs]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Just had a text from a mate that can't wait for next weeks game, he is a Melbourne supporter and reasons they are in for a easy one against us.

[GVGjr]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

I'd consider adding (from) Wallis, Sherman, Dickson, Austin and/or maybe Talia

Outs Smith, Wood and Roughead and maybe one more.

[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Wow, so woeful.

Disagree with the 3 ruckman strategy more than ever but there are also another million things wrong with us so won't harp on about that.

IN/ Sherman, Wallis, Austin
OUT/ Roughead, Smith, Lake

Yep, as much as right now I'd like to see a few more out, I know that's not practical, and I'd settle for these changes.
Big Will will need to show something soon, or else I would propose cutting our losses and just plough some consistent game time into Roughy.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Fans who want to solve our forward issues by playing more talls remind me of Pauline Hanson's idea to fix the economy by printing more money.

It's not talls we are missing, it's quality.

[Rocco Jones]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Yep, as much as right now I'd like to see a few more out, I know that's not practical, and I'd settle for these changes.
Big Will will need to show something soon, or else I would propose cutting our losses and just plough some consistent game time into Roughy.

Yep, long term I see two of Roughy/Cordy/Campbell taking over in the ruck but atm I think it's easy to underestimate the rigours of being the full time number 1 ruck. Not sure any of the kids are up to it and Will playing is probably best for their development.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Not another ruck, a dedicated forward. We need someone to take some pressure off Jones, it maybe a bit old fashion but but I feel we need to settle a player there. I suppose there is no quick fix with the players we have.

Skinner is not in form , Sherman has not improved his disposal efficiency , Panos is being used in the backline with Willi , Hooper is a great little bloke but Dahlhaus has put him in a box labelled " going nowhere " , Tommy Hill is still a little raw , Redpath is still raw and would need to be elevated , Austin can play forward but if elevated will probably play in the backline , Veszpremi has also been used as a rebounding defender with Williamstown , Tom Campbell is also a bit raw but push for selection later this year

So you have a choice of what we have now or what we have have now

.

[LostDoggy]

Re: Match Committee - Round 4 vs Melbourne

Fans who want to solve our forward issues by playing more talls remind me of Pauline Hanson's idea to fix the economy by printing more money.

It's not talls we are missing, it's quality.

Same as the fans calling Higgins to be dropped. Is there an easier target, thought he was one of our better players.